View Full Version : The Best and Worst Transfers Of The Season


jani
03-05-2004, 12:55:AM
Well, I think the season is near a close and its safe to judge new players playing in new teams..

To me, the best transfer of the season has to be Kaká's £5.2m transfer from Sao Paolo to Milan. This transfer was certainly a gamble since Kaká was an unproven player. But Milan's gamble has certainly paid off. Kaká has so far scored 10 Serie A goals playing as Milan's 'trequartista' or better known as the main attacking midfielder. Besides scoring goals, he creates a hell lots of problems for the defence with his sublime pace and silky skills. And another mention should be the way he scores his goals. Almost ALL his goals for Milan have been excellent. My personal favorite has to be the one againts Celta Vigo. And some of you might argue that Ronaldinho has been a better transfer. I beg to differ since Ronaldinho certainly cost maybe 3 or 4 times more than Kaká and was already a household name.

As for the worst transfer of the season, I would give that accolade to Adrian Mutu. He was doing extremely well for Parma before joining Chelsea. And promised great things for the Russian owned club. But unfortunately, he failed to live to expectations. He would have been better staying at Parma and linking up with the future Italian superstar, Alberto Gilardino. But maybe the lure of $$$ was too great an opurtunity to miss. Now he is likely to leave the club and I hope he does better.

RUSI
03-05-2004, 12:59:AM
Kaka was very, very good. So was Tim Howard's transfer.
Ronaldinho and Beckham were pretty good

Mutu was a pretty bad transfer

A bad one was us letting Makelele go and not buying a centre-back

VanTheMan
03-05-2004, 01:05:AM
great thread!

i'll say for man utd it is :the best-c.ronaldo.he has been outstanding and seems a massive one for the future.
the worst-djemba djemba

and for all of football.
i'd say kaka for milan is simply outstanding and only for 5.2m
the worst is also in my opinion mutu for chelsea,just like shevchenko says.

Punkt
03-05-2004, 01:07:AM
for Benfica is simple we only made 4 transfers:

the best: Luisão and Fyssas
the worst: Alex and Thornton.

Daz
03-05-2004, 01:07:AM
Originally posted by VanTheMan

the worst-djemba djemba


c'mon! give the guy a chance! :rolleyes:

Elber2k3
03-05-2004, 01:09:AM
Makaay to Bayern was the best.

The worst: Wichniarek to hertha

:)

Dream Team
03-05-2004, 01:13:AM
Best: Ronaldinho and Kaka, both have been better than everybody expected.

Worst: Veron.

VanTheMan
03-05-2004, 01:14:AM
Originally posted by Dazmania
c'mon! give the guy a chance! :rolleyes:

ok.
i'll say he was the least good out of our 5 buys this season

jani
03-05-2004, 01:15:AM
haha I totally forgot about Veron!

I'd say he has been the worst

(N)

VanTheMan
03-05-2004, 01:20:AM
veron will be the worst wherever he goes.he is too much prone to injuries.
i think he should switch to managing like coleman

Spurs4Life
03-05-2004, 01:22:AM
Best: Ronaldinho without a doubt!.

Worst: Postiga :rolleyes:

Yossarian
03-05-2004, 01:24:AM
Mutu is an attacking/playing midfielder........I blame his unfortunate season on Chelsea for not doing their homework and playing the poor dude out of position

Lean
03-05-2004, 01:25:AM
Best is Kaká and Ronaldinho. Worst got to be Crespo to Chelsea, what a fiasco.

RUSI
03-05-2004, 01:32:AM
I change my mind... Postiga is the worst

unfortuneatly Veron and Crespo have been injured most of the year

If they are healthyI think they'd be great

Crespo has been better than Mutut though;)

shadowofanubis6
03-05-2004, 01:32:AM
Crespo and Mutu never were consistently started, and whenever mutu got hot (remember he was very good at one point...) he'd only be benched by ranieri. Crespo was a mix of being out of shape and the tinkering. The best i think might be tim howard for the cheap price he came for. He's done a great job considering his first year in the premiership and having a bad defense for most of the year to deal with. Kaka certainly a close second for best. The worst? Veron.

Walkeranz
03-05-2004, 01:34:AM
Worst transfer: Crespo to Chelsea and then replacing him with Cruz.
Best transfer: Moratti out Fachetti in

rony31
03-05-2004, 01:42:AM
Best: Kaka to Milan
Worst: every midfielder to join Man City in the off-season

Yossarian
03-05-2004, 01:51:AM
anyone know where the f uck Stephen Dalmat is? Is he still on loan at Tottenham? If so, how has he been? I would really like for Inter to call this awesome player back, man

ogsimon
03-05-2004, 01:54:AM
best: Gaucho
worst Dalmat (LOL)

jani
03-05-2004, 01:55:AM
Spurs just recently kicked him off back to Inter

Amdy Faye
03-05-2004, 02:01:AM
Lol yea he started a fight with a youth player or something lmao?

I wouldnt of thought he was like that!

Anyway for me the best in for Pompey have been Yakubu

The worst was Boris Zivcovic, he was an absolute joke!

I agree too Gaucho has been fantastic. Beckham's done well too.

Crespo has done okay in parts though? So too has Mutu, when ur actually watching them live they're a real threat and are good assets to the team. But I think with all the money in the world, Chelsea should/could of bought the best!

Pontiakos
03-05-2004, 02:14:AM
this was a few years ago.....but this year it is certain that Konstandinou to Panathinaikos was a big mistake...

[ShReK]
03-05-2004, 02:28:AM
Best: Ronaldinho :rockman:
Worst: Postiga :kader:

claupastore
03-05-2004, 02:52:AM
this year kaka was awesome

but instead of looking to the past, ill just say that gilardino will be the best transfer of next season :) :hump:

oh and the worst thing: letting davids go :(

Zlatan
03-05-2004, 03:00:AM
Best: Ronaldinho, Makaay, Kaka
Worst: All those pig buys from Abramovich(except for Crespo that is) and Danko Lazovic

pede54
03-05-2004, 03:04:AM
Originally posted by RUSI
Kaka was very, very good. So was Tim Howard's transfer.
Ronaldinho and Beckham were pretty good

Mutu was a pretty bad transfer

A bad one was us letting Makelele go and not buying a centre-back

Rusi ..please ask Roman if you can have Crapelele..........oops sorry Makelele back.....he is another overated piece of rubbish....thank God he is suspended and cant play this week...we stand a better chance without him.........

Aveirenses
03-05-2004, 03:08:AM
I'm having a deep-laugh inside at all the Postiga nominations for worst transfer. :crazyboy: (H)

Lean
03-05-2004, 03:15:AM
If you consider how much Spurs paid for him and how much goals he scored, he didnt do quite well. Although he hasnt been given much chances. I still think that there are better options in the Tottenham side.

Paulo Da Silva
03-05-2004, 04:02:AM
for Porto:

BEST: Pedro Mendes, Benni, Carlos Alberto
WORST:Maciel, Sergio Conceicao,

Mikey
03-05-2004, 04:07:AM
thinking JUST ABOUT SOCCER REASONS, id say Beckham has been the worst, for the amount they paid for him. Mcmanaman has been a flop for City as well. Kewell has really dissapointed, but they paid very little (than wat he was worth). Veron has been injured, so you cant really call him a flop.

Mikey
03-05-2004, 04:08:AM
Originally posted by Paulo Da Silva
for Porto:

BEST: Pedro Mendes, Benni, Carlos Alberto
WORST:Maciel, Sergio Conceicao,

how has conceicao done? does he play regularly?

cyrex
03-05-2004, 04:11:AM
the best transfers:
Kaka
Ronaldinho

the worst transfers:
uhmm, it's quite difficult to choose... but... I think that...
David Beckham
Adrian Mutu
Juan Veron

Paulo Da Silva
03-05-2004, 04:27:AM
Originally posted by Mikey
how has conceicao done? does he play regularly?

when he first arrived he played regurlarly, but then he started playing like utter **** and has been benched ver since. He played on friday and was once again... ****

Paulo Da Silva
03-05-2004, 04:28:AM
Originally posted by cyrex
the best transfers:
Kaka
Ronaldinho

the worst transfers:
uhmm, it's quite difficult to choose... but... I think that...
David Beckham
Adrian Mutu
Juan Veron

ohhhh. your gonna get some **** from certain supporters. BEckham!!!According to some he's been great, but to me he's had a horrible season. so i agree with you

kickin_kyle
03-05-2004, 06:54:AM
For Rangers....

Best: :rolleyes:

Worst: Capucho, Ostenstad, Emerson, Vanoli

bertkamp16
03-05-2004, 07:17:AM
The best transfer has to be Kaka. I would strangle some one to death to bring that kid to highbury. He's awesome. But not only is he awesome, he's young, the ultimate double threat. Hard to believe that this kid isn't even near his peak. OUCH! He's gonna be absolutely world class in two or three seasons, maybe even sooner than that. I can see him being FIFA WPOY someday.

I don't understand people that consider Becks one of the worst transfers of the season. Considering what a fantastic talent he was before he went to Madrid, it's great to see that he proved all the haters wrong and became even better. Real Madrid's problems have nothing to do with Beckham. I'll tell you the stone cold, no holds barred truth. If Real Madrid were smarter with their money, they would easily be the most awesome force in world football by a mile. But they are more concerned with buying superstars than they are with winning. It's that simple. Real could easily buy world class defenders, and completely fix thier biggest weakness. Instead, they already think they are gonna get a hold of Thierry Henry. What f*cking sense does it make to bring Titi to the Bernabau?? For what they are gonna have to give the Gunners to get them to let him go (50+ mil) they can buy a whole friggin back line of defensive superstars. Another thing, why let Makelele go? He and Helguera were the bomb together. He was easily one of the most important players on the team, even more important than some of their galacticos. Makelele provides a service that is essential to every team, he's a consistent ball winner. But instead, they refuse to play him what he's worth, essentially spitting in his face, and let him run off to Chelsea. I'll stop ranting, but I have one more thing to say. Real would be a better team with Raul and Morientes and an awesome back line than with Henry, Ronaldo, Raul and whoever the hell else they throw into the attack and a crap backline. Period.

AberdeenFC
03-05-2004, 07:18:AM
aberdeen spent 75k on jamie mcquilken from falkirk then after 4 games we released him (H)

Jambo Den
03-05-2004, 07:19:AM
Wyness.

Crusad3r
03-05-2004, 07:21:AM
Worst : Beckham , Quaresma

Best : Ronaldinho, Kaka and Baptista (Sevilla)

Virgo
03-05-2004, 07:25:AM
Originally posted by bertkamp16
The best transfer has to be Kaka. I would strangle some one to death to bring that kid to highbury. He's awesome. But not only is he awesome, he's young, the ultimate double threat. Hard to believe that this kid isn't even near his peak. OUCH! He's gonna be absolutely world class in two or three seasons, maybe even sooner than that. I can see him being FIFA WPOY someday.

I don't understand people that consider Becks one of the worst transfers of the season. Considering what a fantastic talent he was before he went to Madrid, it's great to see that he proved all the haters wrong and became even better. Real Madrid's problems have nothing to do with Beckham. I'll tell you the stone cold, no holds barred truth. If Real Madrid were smarter with their money, they would easily be the most awesome force in world football by a mile. But they are more concerned with buying superstars than they are with winning. It's that simple. Real could easily buy world class defenders, and completely fix thier biggest weakness. Instead, they already think they are gonna get a hold of Thierry Henry. What f*cking sense does it make to bring Titi to the Bernabau?? For what they are gonna have to give the Gunners to get them to let him go (50+ mil) they can buy a whole friggin back line of defensive superstars. Another thing, why let Makelele go? He and Helguera were the bomb together. He was easily one of the most important players on the team, even more important than some of their galacticos. Makelele provides a service that is essential to every team, he's a consistent ball winner. But instead, they refuse to play him what he's worth, essentially spitting in his face, and let him run off to Chelsea. I'll stop ranting, but I have one more thing to say. Real would be a better team with Raul and Morientes and an awesome back line than with Henry, Ronaldo, Raul and whoever the hell else they throw into the attack and a crap backline. Period.


Ronaldo saved Madrid's ass so many times this season...

Aveirenses
03-05-2004, 07:36:AM
For Beira-Mar:

Best: Rui Lima, Whinhjard(sp), and Zemen.

Worst: The mascot :rolleyes: :crazyboy:

Bobby
03-05-2004, 07:43:AM
Best: Stead to Blackburn
Worst: Veron to Chelsea, Postiga to Tottenham...even spurs fans agree

for arsenal:

Best: Clichy
Worst: Didn't have a bad one.

bertkamp16
03-05-2004, 07:47:AM
Originally posted by Virgo
Ronaldo saved Madrid's ass so many times this season...
But they wouldn't need to have their ass "saved" if they had a great backline...

manutd4eva
03-05-2004, 07:49:AM
Best

Ronaldinho
Tim Howard - Bargain of the century.(H)

Worst
Veron

mufc_daddy
03-05-2004, 08:27:AM
Good:

Wolves: Henri Camara
Ronaldinho
Kaka
Baptista
Loan captures of Forsell and Morientes
Cafu: Did allright for Milan at a ripe old age
C. Ronaldo: looks good for the future
Timmy Howard: bargain buy

Bad:

Kewell: Injured and didnt shine as much as he should have
Veron: injury
Mutu: Shy in fron of goal and didnt live up to expectations. He said he only joined for the money.
Crespo: 10 goals in the league (i think) - not much for some one as good as him
Kleberson: hasnt adapted well but when he has played i think he has looked alright. He played well with Ruud. I think becoming a father affected his commitment.
Postiga: sux

Voltaic Borusse
03-05-2004, 08:31:AM
What club was Camara in before he joined Wolverhampton? The guy is ace from what I've seen.

dannyeli
03-05-2004, 08:37:AM
Originally posted by mufc_daddy
Good:

Wolves: Henri Camara
Ronaldinho
Kaka
Baptista
Loan captures of Forsell and Morientes
Cafu: Did allright for Milan at a ripe old age
C. Ronaldo: looks good for the future
Timmy Howard: bargain buy

Bad:

Kewell: Injured and didnt shine as much as he should have
Veron: injury
Mutu: Shy in fron of goal and didnt live up to expectations. He said he only joined for the money.
Crespo: 10 goals in the league (i think) - not much for some one as good as him
Kleberson: hasnt adapted well but when he has played i think he has looked alright. He played well with Ruud. I think becoming a father affected his commitment.
Postiga: sux

Totally right mufc_daddy, but you forgot the loan of Davids with Barca. With Davids Barca has yet to lose a game.

ninobomba
03-05-2004, 09:10:AM
I cant believe u guys forgot about Morientes to Monaco hes been great.

modena_10
03-05-2004, 09:26:AM
best:
kaka to milan
ronaldinho to barca
mancini to roma
chivu to roma
davids to barca(now look at juve, hahaha)
makaay to bayern munich
c.ronaldo to man u
tim howard to man u
saha to man u

worst:
cruz to inter
kily to inter
lamouchi to inter
van der meyde to inter(but give him time)
legrottaglie to juve(give him time)
most of all the chelsea transfers
some man u transfers

SB9Dragon
03-05-2004, 09:57:AM
Best Transfers
Kaka to AC Milan
Mancini to Roma
Davids to Barca
Tim Howard to Man U
Ronaldinho to Barca
Morientes to Monaco

Worst Transfer
Juan "Injury-whore" Veron to Chelsea
Stephane "I beat down on Spur Youth teamers" Dalmat to Spurs

Now an Inter segment :mrpimp:

Best
Stankovic
Adriano
Karagounis (This guy is really good when he is given a chance consistently)
Van der Meyde (This guy may have had a poor season for his standards but I have faith if he gets playing time he can go back to his glory days

Worst
Helveg
Brechet (Went from a French International to crap)
Cruz (This guy started well but he definately is no replacement for Crespo)
Lamouchi (This guy hasn't had a solid game for Inter yet)
Crespo to Chelsea (He left a gap in our strikeforce for the first half of the season)

BRAZIL'S_#9
03-05-2004, 10:38:AM
Originally posted by mufc_daddy
Good:

Wolves: Henri Camara
Ronaldinho
Kaka
Baptista
Loan captures of Forsell and Morientes
Cafu: Did allright for Milan at a ripe old age
C. Ronaldo: looks good for the future
Timmy Howard: bargain buy

Bad:

Kewell: Injured and didnt shine as much as he should have
Veron: injury
Mutu: Shy in fron of goal and didnt live up to expectations. He said he only joined for the money.
Crespo: 10 goals in the league (i think) - not much for some one as good as him
Kleberson: hasnt adapted well but when he has played i think he has looked alright. He played well with Ruud. I think becoming a father affected his commitment.
Postiga: sux

Man how is kleberson doing?

I didn't know he had become a father.:confused:
Well I think that next season, if he doesn't go away, he will play a lot better for manure considering him and ruud play pretty well together. Hey, which position is he playing? I'd really like to see him wear the Brazilian shirt again. Does he play on Scholes position or Keane's?

enigma
03-05-2004, 10:47:AM
Dunno if Clichy's been mentioned.
He's been ace.

Worst is probably Veron. As usual.

mufc_daddy
03-05-2004, 11:27:AM
Originally posted by BRAZIL'S_#9
Man how is kleberson doing?

I didn't know he had become a father.:confused:
Well I think that next season, if he doesn't go away, he will play a lot better for manure considering him and ruud play pretty well together. Hey, which position is he playing? I'd really like to see him wear the Brazilian shirt again. Does he play on Scholes position or Keane's?



He has played just behind Ruud like Scholes and he has played in the centre and also right midfield. He's doine well and done some real classy moves (backheel to Forlan :rockman: :mrpimp: ).

He's been unlucky with injuries though, he's dislocated shoulder blew it for him.

Next year will be good for him.

mufc_daddy
03-05-2004, 11:28:AM
Originally posted by dannyeli
Totally right mufc_daddy, but you forgot the loan of Davids with Barca. With Davids Barca has yet to lose a game.

Yeh good point. How many games is it now? 16?

It would be a dissapointment if they finished below Real.

:)

mufc_daddy
03-05-2004, 11:32:AM
Originally posted by Voltaic Borusse
What club was Camara in before he joined Wolverhampton? The guy is ace from what I've seen.

17 - Henri Camara
Club: Wolverhampton

Shirt Number: 17

Position: Striker

Date of Birth: May 10, 1977

Birthplace: Dakar, Senegal

Height: 5' 10''

Weight: NA



Profile

Camara joined Premiership newcomers Wolverhampton Wanderers for a fee of £1.5million in July 2003.
The Senegal international, who signed a four-year deal, moved to Molineux from Sedan, who had just dropped out of the top flight in France. Sedan went down scoring only 26 goals - but Camara notched 14 of those.

He is a slippery customer out on the right flank, but his failure to provide a decisive finishing touch is often a criticism thrown at him.

Camara enjoyed spells with Strasbourg, Neuchatel Xamax and Grasshoppers Zurich, winning the Switzerland title, before landing at Sedan.

The forward had an impressive World Cup in 2002, scoring twice against Sweden, including the precious Golden Goal, as Senegal reached the quarter-finals of the tournament.

_________________________

I hope he either helps bring Wolves back up or either joins another Premier league club and does well for himself. He had it tough doing the work by himself apart from when Kenny Miller helped him.

Oh well.

northstar
03-05-2004, 11:41:AM
Best: Ronaldinho, Kaka, Davids

Worst: Postiga, Carew,

Some say Veron and Mutu but they were injured so often I dont think its fair to say they had bad years when they didnt get to play much. If they had bad years so did every Man Utd signing. None have done what was expected of them.

aftab
03-05-2004, 11:50:AM
Best
Loan captures of Forsell and Morientes and Davids
glen johnsen, wayne bridge, duff, and parker .
saha and Ronaldinho
Henri Camara- little too late
sheringham - in the beginning of the season he was un stoppable
Ian campo
c.ronaldo
Beckham
Makaay
KOLO toure ( was he bought this season??)
patriik berger
berkovic
solano
cooper (MBORO)
zenden
markus babbel
clichy
kewel- but not consistent

WOrst
crespo
veron
every midfielder to join Man City in the off-season- especially steve Mcmanaman
lehman

jani
03-05-2004, 12:01:PM
Saha, for £12m, couldnt be considered as one of the transfers of the season

Andrew
03-05-2004, 12:03:PM
Best-

Ronaldinho - PSG to Barcelona
Ronaldo - Sporting to ManUtd
Reyes - Sevilla to Arsenal

Worst-

Mutu - Parma to Chelsea
Veron - ManUtd to Chelsea
Kewell - Leeds to Liverpool

aftab
03-05-2004, 12:23:PM
Originally posted by Shevchenko-[7]
Saha, for £12m, couldnt be considered as one of the transfers of the season

scoring crucial goal against arsenal and in the start of his man u career

aftab
03-05-2004, 12:25:PM
Originally posted by Andrew
Best-
Reyes - Sevilla to Arsenal

Worst-

Kewell - Leeds to Liverpool

reyes has yet to prove he can play in the premiership club
as for kewel ???

jani
03-05-2004, 12:28:PM
ur oppions are weird

:|

Saha good but Reyes bad?

northstar
03-05-2004, 12:28:PM
Originally posted by aftab
scoring crucial goal against arsenal and in the start of his man u career

one goal is worth that much money? Maybe Saha is not the player many thought he was.

jani
03-05-2004, 12:31:PM
exactly my point

Saha was bought to score goals but he has only notched a few

Someone like Kaká, coming in from Brazil, into SERIE A, scoring 10 playing midfield, and costing only £5.2m

Surely thats a better buy

Bobby
03-05-2004, 12:33:PM
Lehmann wasen't a bad buy.

He was 1.3m, it's not like we broke the bank on him.

aftab
03-05-2004, 12:38:PM
Someone like Kaká is surely a better buy, but saha hasnt had many games to play for + adjusting at the half way of the season with a new team and scoring goals takes time...

aftab
03-05-2004, 12:45:PM
Originally posted by Bobby
Lehmann wasen't a bad buy.

He was 1.3m, it's not like we broke the bank on him.

it's not like we broke the bank on hi
^^lol :D

i wasnt reffering him as a bad buy but he conceeded some important goals such as in the champioz league as well as in the english liga:kader:

::Jason::
03-05-2004, 12:46:PM
Originally posted by Bobby
Lehmann wasen't a bad buy.
:D :D :D

Kaká has been the best transfer of the season, strongly followed by Howard.

aftab
03-05-2004, 12:50:PM
^^ yes howard i admit is the transfer of da season

jani
03-05-2004, 12:57:PM
how much was he?

aftab
03-05-2004, 01:00:PM
Originally posted by ::Jason::
:D :D :D

Kaká has been the best transfer of the season, strongly followed by Howard.

how much was he?

jani
03-05-2004, 01:04:PM
who?

If ur asking about Howard then u are just :|

Kaká £5.2m

Bobby
03-05-2004, 01:10:PM
Yea, Jens has his mistakes. But i can't understand the critism for a 1.3m keeper. If he was 10m then i could.

Andrew
03-05-2004, 01:15:PM
Originally posted by aftab
reyes has yet to prove he can play in the premiership club
as for kewel ???

Yet to Prove himself? ...you have got to be having a laugh?
2 brilliant goals against Chelsea in the Fa Cup, some of his passing and his assists have been amazing. Reyes is a great player with a very great future ahead of him and as for Saha:rolleyes:

ricardo
03-05-2004, 01:43:PM
In la Liga, the best transfer was Julio Baptista to Sevilla. Ronaldinho owns nowadays but he wasn't too cheap while Baptista was really unknown around here. I guess even Sevilla's board didn't know him quite well; I remember they said he would be the next Mauro Silva (defensive mid) and now look at this:

Ronaldo (Real Madrid) 24
Mista (Valencia) 19
Salva (Malaga) 18
Baptista (Sevilla) 18
Fernando Torres (At. Madrid) 17
Villa (Zaragoza) 17
Tamudo (Espanyol) 16
Eto'o (Mallorca) 15
Milosevic (Celta) 14
Ronaldinho (Barça) 13

jani
03-05-2004, 01:49:PM
he has 18 goals? :|

What position does he play?

WilliamFAlmeida
03-05-2004, 02:25:PM
Wow....the Brazilian transfers were the best I see.....
Ronaldinho has to be the best though...he totally turned it up for Barca!
Kaka has also been fenomenal, as well as Baptista in his new position....
Man U's transfers were the worse I think...fletcher, djemba, bellion, and who? they did nothing this year....maybe next year theyll do better...Cristiano was a good buy....
Reyes ruled for Arsenal...Wenger knows how to transfer.....

Beckham was good for Madrid, but selling Makalele was STUPID!!

Andrew
03-05-2004, 02:37:PM
Wasnt Fletcher produced through the youth system at ManUtd rather than bought in the transfer market:confused:

VanTheMan
03-05-2004, 04:03:PM
william ,you've just talked out any crap.
fletcher was produced via the united youth system

reyes is yet to prove himself at arsenal

makelele has been a jack-a** for chelsea so far.a player of his calibre and proffesion should not have acted like a clown-a** against monaco

gordo_lfc
03-05-2004, 04:18:PM
Best = Kewell to Liverpool
Worst=Duff to Chelsea

VanTheMan
03-05-2004, 04:20:PM
i think duff is one of chelsea's best buys alongwith bridge

jani
03-05-2004, 04:24:PM
Originally posted by gordo_lfc
Best = Kewell to Liverpool
Worst=Duff to Chelsea

That has to be the best first post I've ever seen :crazyboy:

enigma
03-05-2004, 04:31:PM
Originally posted by aftab
i wasnt reffering him as a bad buy but he conceeded some important goals such as in the champioz league as well as in the english liga:kader:

With your logic, Howard has been a bad buy as well.

Originally posted by gordo_lfc
Best = Kewell to Liverpool
Worst=Duff to Chelsea

What the hell are you smoking..

Rob
03-05-2004, 04:44:PM
Best transfer of the season has to be Edgar Davids to Barcelona, Ronaldinho or ... John Stead to Blackburn. He saved them from relegation.

Worst transfer of the season or loan. Roque Junior.

ludde
03-05-2004, 06:07:PM
Best transfers: as follows Ronaldinho, Kaka', Baptista. Howard, C.Ronaldo and Mancini was good buys too. Reyes will be ace. Beckham hasnt been that bad and probably brings in alot of money from asia.

Best loans: Morientes, Davids, Forsell

Worst transfer: I would say Mutu and Veron but considering that the money they paid is nothing to Roman i have to say Postiga to Tottenham.

Worst no transfer: Real Madrid not buying a defender

Most surprising transfer: Reyes to Arsenal

Best "I want a football club" buy: Roman Abramovich

Thelonious
03-05-2004, 06:11:PM
Best
John Stead
Davids
Collins John
Clichy
Kaka
Ronaldinho

Worst
Roque Junior
Kleberson
Mutu
Postiga

Kulixs
03-05-2004, 06:13:PM
Dno y everyone is on Saha's back, hes scored something like 7 in 10 games for man utd, that isnt bad at all. :confused:

Thelonious
03-05-2004, 06:18:PM
Maybe its just a conicidence that when he started playing instead of ruud man utd turned to ****.

Fernandez
03-05-2004, 07:13:PM
Best transfer is probably Ronaldo, Howard or Saha
No one is the worst

PaPaGeorGeo
03-05-2004, 07:20:PM
Jeffers to Everton

enigma
03-05-2004, 08:13:PM
Originally posted by PaPaGeorGeo
Jeffers to Everton

For me that's one of the best transfers in the Premiership.
Should that loan had not taken place, we wouldn't of gotten Reyes, I think. :p

fender
03-05-2004, 09:16:PM
Best: Kaka, Ronaldinho

Worst: Jardel, Postiga and Veron

Oz_Leeds_Fan
03-05-2004, 09:25:PM
For Leeds:

Best: Pennant, no doubt this kid is a future star
Worst:....do i even have to say it? Roque Junior....he is a bloody clown.

tuomas706
03-05-2004, 09:31:PM
best must have been morientes loan to monaco and the worst maybe joe cole to chelsea

KLINSMANN
04-05-2004, 12:18:AM
Best: Ronaldinho, Kaka, Makaay, Martin Max (1860 to Rostock), C. Ronaldo,

Worst: Mutu, Veron, Beckham

Amdy Faye
04-05-2004, 12:21:AM
Why Beckham?

hanek45
04-05-2004, 12:27:AM
Originally posted by KLINSMANN
Best: Ronaldinho, Kaka, Makaay, C. Ronaldo,

Worst: Mutu, Veron, Beckham

Yeah

Bummy_JaB
04-05-2004, 01:52:AM
Well Joe Cole has been playing pretty good lately

Payaah
04-05-2004, 02:01:AM
J.Cole is more likely to go to a new club this summer.

Voltaic Borusse
04-05-2004, 02:15:AM
Best: McBride to Fulham. :p

Dreath
04-05-2004, 02:17:AM
Originally posted by manutd4eva
Best

Ronaldinho
Tim Howard - Bargain of the century.(H)

Worst
Veron
It could Van Persie if he becomes anything like Bergkamp.....

greglato
04-05-2004, 10:28:AM
Worst : Lee Bowyer to Newcastle. He was a free transfer but even that was too much.

BayernBoz
04-05-2004, 10:31:AM
Best: Makaay
Worst: Veron, Crespo, Mutu (All Chelsea Players)

take your pick.......it's one thing having money, it's another knowing what to do with it

mufc_daddy
04-05-2004, 01:36:PM
I think Kevin Davies deserves a mention. He has done well for Bolton and has changed the way people look at them. They are a tough team to beat. He's also put his own career back on track.

Awax
04-05-2004, 01:58:PM
Impossible not to say Makaay. He's scored 30 goals in his first year, 22 of them in the league, 4 goals behind the top sccorer. He's simply amazing. Our midfield isnt that good at the moment, even not in top shape, and he managed to score 30 goals!

Payukgcn
04-05-2004, 05:53:PM
Best: Ronaldinho, Kaka, C. Ronaldo, The loan of Morientes
Worst: Beckham, Rustu, and Queiroz LOL

enigma
04-05-2004, 05:56:PM
Originally posted by Payukgcn

Worst: Beckham

Huh.. Why is Beckham the worst?
Beckham was good business and should not be blamed for Real's disasterous season.
If you want to blame something, blame the transfer of Makelele to Chelsea.

PaPaGeorGeo
04-05-2004, 06:37:PM
You cant say the Veron one was bad He has been Injured like all season give him a chance next year

dobrin1980
04-05-2004, 06:53:PM
Worst - Rustu - his hands are made of cheese.
Best - Ronaldinho - this guy is sooooo great!!!

Chelives
04-05-2004, 08:41:PM
Best: Steve Marlet to Marseille (i.e.best for fulham.)
Worst: Steve Marlet to Marseille

Hans
04-05-2004, 11:13:PM
Best transfer : Kaka

Worst : that Qadafi kid at Perugia . . . :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

Payukgcn
05-05-2004, 05:40:AM
Ok u r right Enigma, Beckham is not a bad player, The Way that Van Gaal i mean Queiroz use him is stupid. This transfer was a bad idea anyway.
In one sentence :
GOOD PLAYER (not a crack) BAD TRANSFER :kader:

bertkamp16
06-05-2004, 06:28:AM
Originally posted by manutd4eva
[b]Best
Tim Howard - Bargain of the century.

Not a chance, bargain"S" of the century: Patrick Vieira, Thierry Henry and Robert Pires:)

SB9Dragon
06-05-2004, 07:01:AM
Originally posted by Hans
Best transfer : Kaka

Worst : that Qadafi kid at Perugia . . . :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

I think you mean Ghaddafi ;)

He may be the worst buy for Perugia but their best definately has to be Ravanelli. Scoring the goal that beat Juve alone made him a great buy (H)

AcesHigh
06-05-2004, 11:25:AM
Who the hell is this Ronaldo playing for Manchester United?


And what about ANTONIO CASSANO?? I dont know if he was transfered this year to Roma, but he sure KICKS ASS!!

Bobby
06-05-2004, 11:26:AM
Originally posted by bertkamp16
Not a chance, bargain"S" of the century: Patrick Vieira, Thierry Henry and Robert Pires:)

Sol and Kolo (H)

SoloLaRoma
06-05-2004, 02:24:PM
kaka was a good transfer, but just as impressive was the transfers of:

Christian Chivu and Mancini (off loan from venezia)

ok we knew chivu was good...but not one of the best D's in the world. Helped Roma get the best defence in Italy. Too bad samuels going :(

Mancini...wow...after playing the benchwarmer in serie B this guy comes out of nowhere....unbelievable and has replace cafu to a tee (Caf-who?)


Worst:

Legrotaglie to Juve....just seeing Moggi so happy he 'stole' him from Roma, and seeing him flop...looks good on that loser Moggi :kader:

jani
06-05-2004, 03:08:PM
Caf-who the guy who captained Brazil to yet another World Cup

Lonestarr022
06-05-2004, 03:59:PM
Has Zach Thornton even played a minute in goal for Benfica?

Lonestarr022
06-05-2004, 04:00:PM
Originally posted by AcesHigh
And what about ANTONIO CASSANO?? I dont know if he was transfered this year to Roma, but he sure KICKS ASS!!


He was with Roma last seson

jani
06-05-2004, 04:05:PM
Originally posted by AcesHigh
Who the hell is this Ronaldo playing for Manchester United?

Hahahahaha

:rofl:

SoloLaRoma
07-05-2004, 12:55:AM
Originally posted by Shevchenko-[7]
Caf-who the guy who captained Brazil to yet another World Cup


ah comeon sarcasm is the spice of life :mrpimp:


No doubt about his achievements and ability, but i remember @ the beginning of the season i was worried about the void left by Cafu - luckily Mancini will prove to be the next Cafu

Rüstü
07-05-2004, 03:24:PM
Best transfer from Turkey Pierre Van Hooijdonk.He has scored 22 goals this season and last 2 weeks.

Worst transfer Frank de Boer. !!!
He was sucks ! and he went to Scotland.(I'm right ?)

Bonzi
07-05-2004, 03:59:PM
the best transfer of the season: Ronaldinho
the worst: Veron

Shindig
07-05-2004, 09:06:PM
Lee Bowyer - Marks his return to European competition by almost getting another ban.