I can't seem to get my defense working, i have 23 GF and 20 GA... The line looks pretty strong to me:

4 3
4 3

That's their balls in tackling and how they're lined up... I also do a...

4 4 3
3

And that doesn't work either. My keepers got 4 balls in keeping too.

The top one is run in a 4-3-3 with a CAM who's my best player on the team. Should I make this guy CDM to help out defense?

The second one is in a 4-5-1 which has been working best for me. I get the best result out of it... unfotunately that leads to mostly ties.

Does anyone have any suggestions?