Replays...

[Interista13]

Hey guys...

I've been following the recent events that have been going on in Italy with all the referees...as you may have heard, due to some (what I think) very bad ref calls, Inter won their match this weekend and that has sparked a few outbreaks among the clubs concerning favoritism and referees...

This has made me wonder a few things which I would like to hear some opinions about…

Do you guys think calciopoli in Italy actually solved anything? I mean violence hasn’t stopped…rage among fans is increasing, and some clubs could still eventually get back to paying referees…they’ll only be more careful…

It seems that referees always get abused for the decisions they make during a game. And if you think about it they really have only a second to see what happened and then quickly make a decision…look at the Inter-Parma match. That “handball” happened in one second and the ref quickly had to make a decision…so…

do you think they should allow replays to the referees like they do in American football or baseball…maybe when something would happen on the pitch the referees could all meet and watch a few replays and discuss it out among each other. This I think would make the calls much more accurate thus making the games a lot fairer. Replays would also prevent clubs from paying the referees to make decisions in their favor…

So, what do you guys think?

 

[El Diablo Rojo]

Even with all the cameras at the stadiums, specially in the big stadiums like some of the italian ones, at times in the case of handballs it's hard to tell it was truely a handball or not, in some cases you'll have 50% of the people saying it was and 50% saying it wasn't, so now you'd let the referee decide and even if it was the same amount of people who'd say "yes" and who'd say "no" still could bring complains about favoritism and fixing, there are other plays where this could happen too, also that even if the referee made the right decision it could take a while, thus longer stoppage time. Also this wouldn't solve the violence issue.

At other sports like Rugby or Basketball where they use replays and such there are still complaints about decisions made by the referees too. Different the case of Tennis where the only thing someone could complain about was totally solved.

 

[lanlanchen]

Hey guys...

I've been following the recent events that have been going on in Italy with all the referees...as you may have heard, due to some (what I think) very bad ref calls, Inter won their match this weekend and that has sparked a few outbreaks among the clubs concerning favoritism and referees...

do you think they should allow replays to the referees like they do in American football or baseball…maybe when something would happen on the pitch the referees could all meet and watch a few replays and discuss it out among each other. This I think would make the calls much more accurate thus making the games a lot fairer. Replays would also prevent clubs from paying the referees to make decisions in their favor…

So, what do you guys think?

if they they have replays? why not choose soccer shoes from www.fine-nike.com,there are have newest fashion shoes

 

[Back Door Skip]

Haha, clever.

 

[yoyo913]

if they they have replays? why not choose soccer shoes from www.fine-nike.com,there are have newest fashion shoes

---------------

But I think the best way to incorporate Replays is to have an extra referee watch a TV and tell the on field ref the correct decision with an ear piece.

 

[tim5303]

Not a big fan

i am not a big fan of replays. If you take rugby for instance then replays for tries can take a number of minutes to decide whether it was atry or not, even then there is debate - take England v South Africa as an example.

Refs make mistakes, as long as they are honest ones then i can live with it

 

[lanlanchen]

Haha, clever.

hahaahahahaaha,thank you,you can choose every thing from it