watch this, bug or not?

[cypp]

http://cypp.rulez.cz/pes5/bug_or_not.avi

my opinion - goal
referee - no goal

 

[Daz]

no goal, the whole of the ball needs to cross the line and from what i can see there, its not all across the line.

 

[gunner_uk2000]

the whole ball was not across the line, a tiny bit of the ball is obscured by the post at the end. so no it's not a goal.

Although in the real world ie without nanometer perfect line/offside decsions you might have got it.

I've had a goal disallowed for offside, and upon viewing the replay my forwards foot was a tiny (ie milimeters) bit ahead of the defender when the ball was played :boohoo:

 

[cypp]

ok

some goals (6*)

http://cypp.rulez.cz/pes5/galletti_1a.avi
http://cypp.rulez.cz/pes5/galletti_1b.avi

http://cypp.rulez.cz/pes5/arizmendi_1a.avi
http://cypp.rulez.cz/pes5/arizmendi_1b.avi

 

[snakeranyking]

not a goal by a tiny bit

 

[Calenulma]

A referee shouldn't agree on a goal unless he was sure. That's a tough decision.