Read the whole history please: Plagiarism

[Tha_Trxth]

Well, first at all, sorry, i don't know where to put this one, so i put this one here, if it's not on the right place, let me know.
I REPORTED THIS ONE AND NOTHING! SO, PLEASE READ.
I will tell you the whole history...

http://www.soccergaming.com/forums/showthread.php?t=172609
27-01-2012: The user benlanie, author of the bolivian and uruguayan league discovered that a user was doing plagiarism, benlanie only gives his works via MP, well, he discovered that another user was making plagiarism because he found one of his patches on a blog, he wasn't put as the author, instead of he, there was another guy as the author.
you need to know, benlanie made up the Bolivian LFPB and Uruguayan League, and harry_pc24 made up the Qatar Stars League well, the images speak theirselves.
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/21/46544263.jpg/
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/811/40567905.jpg/

28-01-2012: The user jcvoltio, leader of the F07 Megapatch Project discovered a sliver of the identity of the thief, he discovered that the thief was called johan or something like that.
http://www.soccergaming.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3173140&postcount=14

Well, the user in fact was johanbc, he was trying to negate what he done, but he was sooooo obvious.
http://www.soccergaming.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3173166&postcount=20

The post is in spanish too, so here is a translation.

Stoooop, Stop, Stop, i'm going to tell you the truth
I'm friend of the guys of that blog, i gave them the links of the Qatari and Bolivian leagues and i told them that i got the link from a site... the things that i have passed, i told them that were from this site, also, you won't know who are the 2 guys, they have an account on this site, but i'm not going to tell you, because they will say that i'm accusing.

well, after that, vicoto09, one of our best kitmakers said that the user johanbc was stalking him on facebook, calling himself "Tan Show".
http://www.soccergaming.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3173263&postcount=22
the post is in spanish and is long, so here is the short version.

He (johanbc) have a strange way to act... he's like a stalker, we have to get him near in order to make him stop annoying us, he only want to gain respect taking the other guys' work...

well, johanbc answered the bad.
http://www.soccergaming.com/forums/newreply.php?do=newreply&p=3173518

Now vicoto, you joined the group on facebook and you said that we can freely use your kits, also, i didn't know that the kits were yours, and why are you calling me stalker?

To conclude, this banner made by Mati23.

It says, "In Soccer Gaming We Valorate The Work"

Well, the demands from the 07 Forum users are quite simple, we want the user johanbc to be exiled or he'll keep doing this, we don't like the users that take others material and say that it's of their authority.

 

[yoyo913]

We are taking a look at it, thanks for posting.

 

[Tha_Trxth]

We are taking a look at it, thanks for posting.

thanks

 

[vicoto09]

good job dood.. thanks

 

[Mati23]

Very good to Thread
Stop plagiarism

 

[benlanie]

Amazing Job Brother! Thanks!

 

[yoyo913]

I contacted johanbc and he replied:


Si me dejas esta vez defenderme te explico bien el caso.. sabes que le pase a un amigo que tiene un blog algunas ligas de aqui de soccergaming estadios y eso que tambien creo que ek esta en soccergaming es moises torquaro cuando yo le pase el material se lo pase por facebook pero claro yo a el no le dije que era mio y pues sabes que jc vicoto me tiene bronca por un problema que tuvimos en facebook y pues la agarro conmigo y dijo que yo soy el plagiador


Do you guys have enough proof to merit a ban? Seems like you are sure it is him but he is saying that it is not him.

Also, you guys can't speak Spanish like this, I don't even understand the thread and can't make a decision based on it. This forum is in English and people like to know what people are talking about, the rules are to only speak in English. Other language is allowed in special circumstance but only if a translation is provided bellow it.

Part of the rules:

Article 11: Forum Languages :
Posting in Foreign Languages In order for the harmony and usibility of the SG forums to be preserved, it is essential that all users can understand each others posts, and therefore necessary for all posts to be in the same language. As the vast majority of our visitors are English speakers, it makes sense that all posts are made in English, and therefore it is now a breach of SG rules to post in any language other than English outside the Other Language forums. In the rare occasion that you have a good reason for posting in a foriegn language, it is essential that you provide an English translation. Anyone who persistantly posts in a language other than English, outside forums where English is not the primary language, will recieve only one warning before a yellow card is issued, and a red card will is issued if the offender still persists.

 

[yoyo913]

He added

"puess I am not the owner of the blog ... the author comes out in some leagues out with my name on facebook so show but like I said it and I never said that leagues were made ​​by me which climbed all this is also a Brazilian because there are some flags that are not mine"

He claims he did not say he made the patch, he was just posting it, sharing it with others.

 

[Tha_Trxth]

He added

"puess I am not the owner of the blog ... the author comes out in some leagues out with my name on facebook so show but like I said it and I never said that leagues were made ​​by me which climbed all this is also a Brazilian because there are some flags that are not mine"

He claims he did not say he made the patch, he was just posting it, sharing it with others.

ok, fine, now i understand the whole situation, when he posted on the thread where he was accused of plagiarism his posts were confusing, now that i understand his whole version, i gotta say that i'm sorry

 

[yoyo913]

You should probably apologize to him, might have hurt his feelings.

 

[Tha_Trxth]

my apologies
http://www.soccergaming.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3184904&postcount=46

Translation

well, now johanbc explained everything, he never told that the bolivian or qatari league was made by himself, he told that the guys of the blog "equipe07" made an ERROR on the credits, i believe this in part, knowing that blog, they are like "hasted", because they put the credits "the fast way", for example, when they posted the balls of vicoto09, he (vicoto09) made up an image with the real name of the author, in this case, the ball for euro 2012, by theeminemfan and with some edits by vicoto, but the guys of the blog thinked that vicoto made up the whole ball, check the image, you can see that is written "THEEMINEMFAN"
http://equipefifa07.blogspot.com/2012/01/bola-da-euro-copa-2012.html

i think that in part wasn't the fault of johanbc, the only error that he made was sending the links (benlanie only send his patches via MP, i think, because is a patch by and for sg, that way, no other sites can have it) but, the thing that johanbc did was an error, i don't know, i think that this case is closes, what do you think?, in my opinion, i owe my apologies to johanbc because we accused him "the fast way" before we can clear the whole situation, we maybe made a mistake because we didn't saw the whole picture, opinions?, coments?

UPDATE to the history:

johanbc accepted the apologies.
http://www.soccergaming.com/forums/newreply.php?do=newreply&p=3184905

I accept your apologies, also i think that i was an error to send the leagues to Moises Torquato and don't tell him who made it

benlanie, the main denouncer also made his apologies.
http://www.soccergaming.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3184988&postcount=49

There's no drama bro i want that we all work together and don't let fifa07 die.

everything is solved friend... i only want respect for the work and the credits... just that... and... nothing... welcome again... let's work again now bro that way we can make fifa07 the best one

to finish
http://www.soccergaming.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3185222&postcount=50

I just wanna that this thread get closed

well, now that this case has been solved, this thread is not necesary anymore, i want to request that the thread http://www.soccergaming.com/forums/showthread.php?t=172609 gets closed, the case is now solved.