Youre Opinion?

[PaPaGeorGeo]

Do you think players in Cm4 Peek To Early? By this i mean that they are playing the best they can at the age of 22,23,24

 

[PSVFOREVER]

yeah, Adu playing with stars when he is 15 is pretty unrealistic

 

[PaPaGeorGeo]

Yeh i also think with alot of players they start to play at the best when there 26+ apart from the odd superstar Ronaldo who was better when he was younger

 

[PSVFOREVER]

I prefer defense and Mid to be like 26 or 27. not too old. My wingers and strikers are often already good enough when they reach 20/21 IMO

 

[Lean]

And Ronaldo is "worst" than before more because of injuries than anything else. I totally agree with PSVFOREVER, i dont like using young defenders (except for Gareth Barry and John Terry) and dont like putting young holding midfielders. I prefer more experienced DM's, as for att. mids, i like to use the younger ones like Kaka, D'alessandro and the likes, for forwards someone around 20-22 is good enough.

 

[PaPaGeorGeo]

What iam saying is that players in general in this game reach there peak at a young age which isnt like real life where players peak at between 26-29

 

[PSVFOREVER]

It's true, but I still prefer older defenders and mids

 

[Tom]

i think you see so many older DM's BECAUSE they are better as DM's, thats why CM is realistic, as for CB's, well, i think its ok to have a younger one as long as they are with another more experienced one.

I think for creative midfielders young can be better, but creativity is often better in older players. which is true to life.

As for strikers, well, thats when you want a mix, somwehere beween 25-29 in my view.

As for Keepers, under 25 is just too young, with the odd exception.

TROD.

 

[champdave]

My defence on FV is McEvely - Lescott - Fortune (John, former Charlton player) - Leigeterwood

Next England lineup

I don't know why, just my younger defenders are better, and none of my old players have more than jumping +15, which I consider an important trait in defender.

 

[Tom]

yeah, classic attributes for the CB:

Tackling, Marking, Jumping, Heading, Positioning, Anticipation, Pace, Acceleration.

TROD. Plus a few other physical ones.

 

[Áļéאָ]

yeah we're not asking much from a CB... He just has to be perfect

 

[Sukur54]

i have this kid named Sabri Sarioglu (Galatasaray) who is 20 and he played a 8.00 avarage in 30+ games when he was 19. and right now hes 20 and hes playing a 9.00 with 30+ and going games left in the season and hes only 20! this is too unrealistic i think but hey hes winning me my trophies.

 

[Áļéאָ]

Maybe he needs a transfer to a better league and playz good to satisfy the scouters

 

[Sukur54]

well turkish league isnt that bad but also he plays like this in champions league too and hes in the national team already and plays like this there too. and im not letting him go i make him sign the longest contract possible every 2 years.

 

[Tom]

CM is unrealistic with CB's. they are far too good too young.

TROD. Not enough emphasis is put on experience.

 

[Áļéאָ]

Turkish league is bad... the Italian. English and Spanish leagues (+ Germany and maybe Holland) are much better leagues... Unofortunately for the rest of the world, all the best players, managers are there