Turnbull
Paulo - Bruma - Terry - Aanholt
Yossi - Ramires - Zhirkov
Sturridge - Anelka - Kakuta
That was bad. I would like to commend the attitude of the players for getting back into the game, but that was so poor. After Patrick got himself a goal, we were dominating, then no one of Paulo, Yossi or Ramires closes Ferguson down and Patrick doesn't defend properly and then we collapsed and conceded again. Kalou and Yossi down with injuries and we played with 10 men for half an hour. A lot of mistakes from pretty much everyone, and all of the goals were hugely avoidable, very disappointing.
Turnbull: Weak, weak performance. Made one good save, and it looked unintentional. Hilario is injured, but it doesn't matter, I'm not liking either of them. Turnbull simply isn't good enough and because of him we've gone from no goals at the Bridge and 2 conceded so far, to conceded 4 in one match at the Bridge. He was useless at the free-kick and could've saved the latter goals too.
Paulo: Wore the armband at the 2nd half, he was decent, but lost several balls and is partially at fault for 2 goals.
Terry: got subbed at halftime for Alex, got a run-out but did nothing noteworthy, although he didn't look his best.
Bruma: Buckled under the pressure, and didn't show much promise. He wasn't terrible, but again, at fault for at least one goal and contributed few positives.
Alex: The most solid in defense, and I'm glad, because he's really stepping up this year. He was the one who was supposed to track Ameobi in that last goal but I think that's more Turnbull's fault. Went forward when we were searching for a goal, and wasn't bad in defense. Not a good showing, but amongst the better ones today.
v.Aanholt: Definitely better going forward than in defense. Lost his man in the 1st goal and needed Zhirkov around to help, but was directly involved in 2 goals and looked good going forward, although in the 1st half when he surged forward more, he seemed too eager to get the ball in the middle, and didn't go to the byline enough, or even hold onto the ball. Very talented, but need more discipline.
Ramires: is. not. Mikel. Not even close. So why was he played in that role? Failed to impress, and looked more comfortable when McEachran came in and he got more liscence to go forward. It showed that we had no true holding mid because no one was playing the ball properly through the middle (although Toon pressed high up so there was little room). I'm still waiting for him to play up to his price tag. Not the worst today, but still hasn't done anything noteworthy in any of his matches. Needs to settle in, and maybe get played in a role he's good at. Not. DM. Please.
Zhirkov: One of the better guys out there. With 2 youngsters on the left, he took control of that side it's no coincidence that we stopped attacking well down there when he had to wander to the centre. Allowed Patrick to surge forward, and was pretty good, although as with everyone, not good enough.
Yossi: I hope he's alright, because he looked quite good out there. Lost his markers and played some good passes, although I think Ramires expected him to cover Ferguson, but he was too far away. Probably one of the best out there today (still, not at the expected level), especially because he looked like the only one able to breach Newcastle's high line.
Kakuta: Looked lively, showed some good glimpses of his ability, but found it hard to penetrate the defense, and started disappearing. Got subbed for Kalou at half-time, and Kalou wasn't on the field for even 10 minutes, so there's nothing to say about him. Hope he's ok, we need him, despite his inconsistencies, in the next few weeks.
Sturridge: Poor. Really, he's a worse version of Kalou. Lost balls, tried to be an individual and failed to do anything good all game. Not good enough, even for a youngster.
Anelka: Decent performance, scored 2 goals, one of them a very cold-blooded penalty. The fact that all 3 strikers liked to pick the ball up from midfield allowed Newcastle to play a high-line easily, and although he was our best forward by far, a standard CF to keep the CBs penned back would've been better. I think Borini instead of Sturridge would've been better. Looked dangerous, but far from his best match.
McEachran: This kid is the ****. When he came on we were chasing the game and shortly after we were down to 10 and you couldn't tell he was nervous at all. Best youngster out there and had he actually affected the scoreline somehow I would even give him MoM, but he didn't. Still, he looked brilliant. He took over the non-defensive duties of the Mikel role, and built the attack well. He never lost the ball, even won it a few times, was unbelievably calm, dribbling past challenges with ease and great composure. He reminded me of Xavi a bit: didn't lose the ball, held his own when challenged, and made good passes in the middle, although nothing quite as incisive in the final third, although with 10 men and everything he had against him, I'm very, very pleased with him. Give him more minutes, Carlo.
So, we're out of the Cup, which is only a shame because it means the youngsters have less matches to play in, other than that, I couldn't care less. I just care about the fact that we lost, and we should've done better. The team got rattled too easily and the midfield trio didn't click.
I hope Kalou and Yossi are fit for City, or as soon as possible. Lamps will probably miss the City match, but Terry should be fit.
Oh, and Bosingwa played in a reserve match today, 55 minutes.