• This is a reminder of 3 IMPORTANT RULES:

    1- External self-promotion websites or apps are NOT allowed here, like Discord/Twitter/Patreon/etc.

    2- Do NOT post in other languages. English-only.

    3- Crack/Warez/Piracy talk is NOT allowed.

    Breaking any of the above rules will result in your messages being deleted and you will be banned upon repetition.

    Please, stop by this thread SoccerGaming Forum Rules And Guidelines and make sure you read and understand our policies.

    Thank you!

Common Sense

twigsanberries

Youth Team
This issue is so bad, I have decided to make it public and ask for assistance. I had already played about 4 seasons into the game before the .2 patch came out. Did not want to lose my progress with my favorite team, so i decided to stick it out. However, one problem has persisted for as long as I've had the game. We all know about the strikers not finishing, the offsides problems, the injuries piling up, chairmen being retarded, etc... BUT! This one problem has me screaming.

Defenders.

My CBs are constantly beaten by the 1-2 combo. No matter how much of a beat they have on the ball, the opposing player will get to it first, and will wait for his teammate while my defender does nothing. Then, when the opposing teammate gets there, they will play the 1-2 pass, and they will have a 1v1 against my keeper. Not only that, but my defenders will constantly take the most asinine paths to dead balls, that 60-70 % of the time they will get beaten. Against my leauge teams, I can do okay, but in a European competition, I absolutely get murdered. No amount of training has improved this, and I have trolled and asked for help, gotten everything possible to try and rectify this. Being a team that pretty much nobody wants to join, I have to troll 3rd world countries for talent, which makes this arduous enough already. But even when I got 2 very very good CBs, whose stats are good enough to warrant a place on some very good clubs, they make the same mistakes that my CBs from my youth club make.

I have tried setting them to Ultra Defensive, with no dribbling, no running forward, with closing down only when the opposition is close, and still no effect. It is almost like there is absolutely no common sense. None. I must ask - does anybody have this problem with the new patch...? I feel very bad scrapping this game, I am now in my 9th season, this is a club for which I actually played youth football for, and I have developed some players, and would not want my progress to be for naught. However, I am so infuriated by now that I would seriously start over, if this idiotic problem is gone. I've played every version of FM (or CM) whatever you wish to call it, since 01/02. Never have I seen such a humongous problem. Sorry for the rant.
 

Filipower

Bunburyist
Well you're absolutely correct, the expressions 'FM08' and 'common sense' just don't fit together, that's a fact.
 

Johnny_Big

Starting XI
Deep defensive line and low width usually helps. CBs have everything rarely for me and defensive 3 ticks above ultra defensive. No Creative Freedom, low pressure and hard tackle (yeah, we are no pussies here).

Put a defensive midfielder helping the CBs, maybe.

This is very subjective, but it's simple actually.
 

twigsanberries

Youth Team
see that's the problem... it is absolutely asinine for me to change my formation because the game does not follow the rules I set. They are set to ultra defensive, no creative freedom, and they only pressure when someone is in their own area. I just don't get it. Maybe it is the old patch, and it was fixed in the new one, since I've heard nobody else complain about it.

Also, my LB and RB constantly run with the ball... even though they have the same instructions as my CBs. my passing is mixed, not focused down the flanks, otherwise i would understand. just weird man...
 

Rocky

Forza Suarez! (ps brotha can you spare a dime?)
If you installed the patch but continued a save from an earlier version of the game, it might not have fixed all the bugs. Try starting a save game with 8.0.2 and see if you notice anything different about your defenders.
 

twigsanberries

Youth Team
that's the problem, i never installed the patch on the new game. i was so far ahead, and was informed that the patch does not take effect on the saved games. i didn't want to lose my progress. but at this point, there is just no reason to continue. with these lapses, i would never get past the better talent in the european competitions, so i guess i will restart with the new patch and see what happens. i was just wondering if anybody had the same problem with defenders. must be just me though.
 

Mus

Fan Favourite
you dont loose your progres... just test one with the new patch (database) and see if it makes a difference if not go back to your old one
 


Top