• This is a reminder of 3 IMPORTANT RULES:

    1- External self-promotion websites or apps are NOT allowed here, like Discord/Twitter/Patreon/etc.

    2- Do NOT post in other languages. English-only.

    3- Crack/Warez/Piracy talk is NOT allowed.

    Breaking any of the above rules will result in your messages being deleted and you will be banned upon repetition.

    Please, stop by this thread SoccerGaming Forum Rules And Guidelines and make sure you read and understand our policies.

    Thank you!

no matter if u find it stupid or not...fifa's statement about corinthians world title

tinytim

Youth Team
some months ago, i spent some time and words here trying to find out peoples' opinion about corinthians world title in 2000.

i got out of the discussion feeling that the world was 'bambinized' - yes, we call bambi sao paulo fans, who are the biggest opponents to the idea that corinthians it is actually a world champion, regardless of playing a libertadores cup...well, that's what happened with france, uruguay, argentina, germany and other countries that staged world cups.

instead of promoting a discussion - no matter if that would be transformed in a board of jokes over corinthians comparing to other clubs, as it happened here, with many germany club fans (a certain deisler) being quite rude about how 'big' bayern munich is, i also had to take an uruguayan fan use this space to kinda...hmmm...promote a 'self-help' (is it correct?) or 'confession' session, saying how unfair history had been with uruguay.

man, what a lame discussion. i promised myself don't ever come back here for that, because that made me sick. oh of course...i didn't want to participate in international fights over matters that are officially recognized...just be a little bit less ignorant and read more, and anyone can realize that.

anyway...who cares? i'm gonna post it here, anyway...no matter how much the big wise smart brainiac football guys here find it stupid or wrong. if u wanna disagree, that's ur problem. understand what fifa says about it and if u, south american...obsessed with libertadores, can't recognize it...or u sao paulo fan bambi, will never do it anyway...or u european, don't give a damn...to the hell with all of u.

here are some cuts and highlights from this text of fifa offic. web site:


http://www.fifa.com/en/comp/Clubworld/tournament/0,4133,CWC-2006-104,00.html



The idea to hold a championship to decide the world’s best team was dreamt up in the late 1950s. During those post-WWII years when sport was helping the world come together and soothe painful memories of conflict, football in Europe and South America continued its global dominance.

So as competition club football grew up with the introduction of the European Cup (1955/5) and the Copa Libertadores (1960), it was only natural that the Intercontinental Cup should be a match between clubs from these two distant continents.

But with so much riding on the matches, passions, on and off the pitch, had begun to get out of control by the late 1960s and while South American teams still viewed it as their ultimate club contest, European sides had largely come to regard the annual challenge as being more trouble that it was worth.

With the noble idea seemingly approaching a lingering death, Japan stepped in as saviours in 1980 offering to stage a one-off match, the Toyota Cup in Tokyo (latterly Yokohama).

One thing was missing though – a true world club tournament needed clubs from the whole world.

Continental club championships had long since kicked off in all confederations. First in the North, Central America and the Caribbean (CONCACAF) in 1962, then in Africa (CAF) in 1965, in Asia (AFC) in 1967, while Oceania (OFC) did not organise a tournament until 1999. World class stars were rapidly emerging from these new footballing lands but, unlike Pele in 1962, those top players were disallowed from being able to pit their wits against those from European and South American clubs because of the exclusivity of the championship.

The idea to stage a global club competition pre-dated the ultimate Toyota Cup. Having seen the financial might of European club sides only increase at the end of the 20th century and with the goal of uniting and promoting the game fairly in the football world, FIFA had wrestled with the notion of including a multi-confederation club competition on the international match calendar for some time.

In January 2000 those plans were realised when eight teams contested the first FIFA Club World Championship in Brazil, which was won by Corinthians. The second tournament did not take place as scheduled though as discussions across the globe continued in order to reach a compromise between finding space in an already rich match calendar and upholding the principle of a viable club competition involving champions from each continent.

A solution was reached in 2004. The FIFA Club World Championship would build on the foundations laid by the Toyota Cup with the six continental champions participating in a knockout tournament.



Winners
Intercontinental Cup

1960 Real Madrid
1961 Peñarol
1962 Santos
1963 Santos
1964 Internazionale
.
.
.
.
1977 Boca Juniors
1978 No competition
1979 Olimpia


Toyota Cup
1980 Nacional
1981 Flamengo
1982 Peñarol
1983 Grêmio
.
.
.
1992 São Paulo
1993 São Paulo
.
.
.
2005 São Paulo

FIFA Club World Championship Brazil 2000
Corinthians

remember: fifa said that a true competition should be created and the text 'links' it right after to the WCC in 2000.

more:

http://www.fifa.com/en/comp/Clubworld/tournament/0,6537,CWC-2006-106,00.html


okdok?
 

Hendrik

Team Captain
Dude, no one gives a **** about this worthless Cup. You can post as many articles as you want to prove your point on this subject, it won't change a tiny bit.
 

pasion1

Senior Squad
-Vince- said:
Dude, no one gives a **** about this worthless Cup. You can post as many articles as you want to prove your point on this subject, it won't change a tiny bit.

Except all of SOuth America, recently North America, Asia, Africa, Oceania and teams who have actually won it in Europe.........yeah besides ALL THOSE PEOPLE , no one cares :funny:

I do give more importance to the Libertadores, but our third Intercontinental in 1988 vs. PSV Eindhoven was too priceless to be true.
 

emmer

Senior Squad
i'm kind of "europocentric" (?) on this subject. i hate how the brazilian media hypes this competition up.

last year são paulo simply despised the national league because of the world championship, i'd hate if my team did such thing.

by the way, i am brazilian and i support corinthians.
 

pasion1

Senior Squad
Yeah say what you want. But I was telling "Vince" not to be a rude asshole, that's all.

To some people this means alot. People cry for Intercontinental finals.

Imagine if a small team in Germany battled and battled (not saying Corinthians is a small team btw) for like 50 years bulding a team, then goes on to win the UEFA Cup (not the CL) and in front of all their fans they celebrate it as the greatest day in the history of the team and some could say city. The tears are running with job after so much heartbreak, fighting and suffering.

you go online to celebrate the win and 99% of the Posters go: "Dude WHO GIVES A **** ABOUT THE UEFA CUP...........It's the CL that matters"

Then you'd know how that feels. (For ex, I dont know many people who can even give a **** about the UEFA cup, I'd rather win a derby against my worst rival than that cup, But I bet you that people in Middlesbrough (sp?) are taking it as if it was the Final of the World Cup, .........point is, show some damn respect.
 

Hendrik

Team Captain
pasion1 said:
Yeah say what you want. But I was telling "Vince" not to be a rude asshole, that's all.
tinytim has quite a history of bringing up these stupid arguments over and over again. His inferiority complex is indeed very similar to yours.

Need proof?

http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=129085
http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=124928
http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=124925
http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=125005

He can enjoy being a "World Champion" all he wants.
I, and I'm not the only one, rate this World Cup of Clubs or the International finals about as high as the Intertoto Cup. Could you imagine a fan of some random club that won it 6 years ago still going on about it? :rolleyes:
 

El Diablo Rojo

Starting XI
Well it's said that Boca has 15 international cups but 2 of these would not really count since one is the "Masters cup" and the other one whose name i don't remember but they would kind of pre-season tournaments. So in reality they have 13, so it's a bit weird how International cups are considered really.:jambo:

Also you Independiente won the Intercontinental in 1973 and 1984, and Independiente was going to the one in 1975 against Bayern München but the german side didn't want to play it, the year after they did play against Cruzeiro, which got Independiente's managment mad and since 1976 are reclaiming for the Intercontinental to be played, and for what i've heard they would looking for a proper date for it to be played since some months ago.:o
 

slowdive

Club Supporter
pasion1 said:
Except all of SOuth America, recently North America, Asia, Africa, Oceania and teams who have actually won it in Europe.........yeah besides ALL THOSE PEOPLE , no one cares :funny:
.
My team, Porto, won 2 times and i don't care much :ewan:
 

pasion1

Senior Squad
-Vince- said:
tinytim has quite a history of bringing up these stupid arguments over and over again. His inferiority complex is indeed very similar to yours.

Need proof?

http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=129085
http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=124928
http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=124925
http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=125005

He can enjoy being a "World Champion" all he wants.
I, and I'm not the only one, rate this World Cup of Clubs or the International finals about as high as the Intertoto Cup. Could you imagine a fan of some random club that won it 6 years ago still going on about it? :rolleyes:

yeah. Boca Juniors/ River Plate (both those clubs are bigger than 80% of the German league, put together :p ) and they consider these wins to be their greatest acomplishments (as much as libertadores)

Anyways, Olimpia, Nacional, Penarol, Sao Pablo (in 92/93) ....well pretty much every team in SOuth America that won it.
(Once Caldas lost the final 2 years ago and the players were so depressed and sad that they cried on the field for over 30 minutes after the PKs ended)

Its different than Europe. In South America they hype the game from THE DAY that they win the Libertadores (As the famous line when Boca took the last PK in 2000 ......It wasnt "Boca to win the Cup"......but : "Real MAdrid awaits Boca if they can score", as if this was only a "semi final" type deal.

All the radio shows, soccer shows, football commercials, talk shows, clip shows.......everything hypes the game up for 1 whole year until the game (Boca/Milan was sureal, it was all they spoke about for the few months before and "what players to use")

Of course some are more important than others. IE: The 1966 one where Real Madrid had arguably their greatest team ever vs. Penarol's greatest team ever. The war of medias and fanatics that happened months before that game was incredible (So much that Real Madrid fans almost rioted , which i think never happened in history, when Penarol won 2-0 in Spain). But that was a wierd one (it wasnt even the cup that mattered, but both teams just really wanted to prove who was better <since back then South America was as good if not better than Europe>)

But Intertoto cup? Common no one can be THAT dumb.

We know it's Europe who doesnt care much, but in between world clubs (especially south america), they see use this cup as huge bragging rights.

(it's like imagine Middlesbrough won the UEFA cup (prob will), and they go to a World Tour as the "UEFA Cup champs", and all of South American media, Asian media, USA, whover..............said "What the hell is the UEFA Cup?"

Dude, I'd like be dead. (So i can imagine how that guy feels about that <corinthians guy>)

But whatever, I can see no way of comparing each continent's trophies to each other. All I know is we have 8 Libertadores, and that does matter, even worldwide (I think that's more than all the nations besides Brazil and Argentina combined........lets see
Paraguay- 3
Colombia -2
Ecuador -1
Chile- 1 :p
Mexico-0
Ecuador- 0
Bolivia- 0
Venezuela-....never mind...
----
Brazil has like 13 i think. All i know is Argentina has the most with like 15 or 16. (dont quote me on the numbers)

yup :rockman:
 

pasion1

Senior Squad
untouchable said:
What's a FIFA Club World Championship?

Its this thing that Man U only has 1 of, cause they lost in the 60s (in one of the most infamously violent ass kickings Estudiantes ever gave an English team) and that they need to win Champions' leagues to go. (Which Liverpool won 5 and Man U won 1? 2? ...who cares, point is Liverpool Rules England and Man U in international cups :D
 

Kibe Kru

Starting XI
untouchable said:
What's a FIFA Club World Championship?
You may know it better as "the inferiority complex heaven". To S. Am. clubs it's a "chance to get one over the europeans that come here to get our best players". To Euro clubs it's not anything important. To Liverpool supporters this season it's the reason they had a slump when chasing Chelsea.

Lastly, and most importantly, it's a competition that can get you some easy money on Football Manager.
 

pasion1

Senior Squad
i find it incredible that South America still manages to beat Europe even though they need South American players to make their teams Great. (Like I dont know what they should try next.......buying out the actual Club and forcing them to lose before the game?)
 

El Diablo Rojo

Starting XI
About Europe not caring, probably they find it shameful that the champions of their beloved Champions League loses to a non-european team. For example Estudiantes LP beating Manchester United at Old Trafford in 1968.

pasion1, just to add to the Libertadores matter...

Independiente has 7 - 1964, 1965, 1972, 1973, 1974, 1975, 1984.
Boca Junios has 5 - 1977, 1978, 2000, 2001, 2003.
Estudiantes LP has 3 - 1968, 1969, 1970.
River Plate has 2 - 1986, 1996.
Argentinos Juniors has 1 - 1985.
Racing Club has 1 - 1967.
Vélez Sarsfield has 1 - 1994.

Which gives the total of 20.:jambo:
 

pasion1

Senior Squad
El Diablo Rojo said:
About Europe not caring, probably they find it shameful that the champions of their beloved Champions League loses to a non-european team. For example Estudiantes LP beating Manchester United at Old Trafford in 1968.

pasion1, just to add to the Libertadores matter...

Independiente has 7 - 1964, 1965, 1972, 1973, 1974, 1975, 1984.
Boca Junios has 5 - 1977, 1978, 2000, 2001, 2003.
Estudiantes LP has 3 - 1968, 1969, 1970.
River Plate has 2 - 1986, 1996.
Argentinos Juniors has 1 - 1985.
Racing Club has 1 - 1967.
Vélez Sarsfield has 1 - 1994.

Which gives the total of 20.:jambo:

God damn. You put us to shame :nape: .

Yeah lol, I rememeber when The Reds (forgot city name) from Japan didnt beat, destroy, but RAPED Manchester United in the 2-0 win in Hong Kong (think it was). The players (scholes, Rud Van were visibly sweating and frustrated that they were getting bitched so bad)

And then Fergie said after the game that "Japan hasnt surpassed England in Football because Manchester United wasnt trying :funny: "

In Japan though, they actually didnt see it as much of a surprise as they were confident that they could beat Man U with that team (which was the 2nd place of Japan at that time).

Point is- Entire world has advanced so much its incredible.
And the GREAT part is that the Asian market is very strong (IE: They pay well and dont need to sale to Europe)

Europe is capitalizing on South America mainly...............as South America is capitalizing on Africa (Europe too in a way). But if South America was to stabalize in a 10-20 years, then things would go back to the 80s (IE: south america not selling to Europe like the last 10 years. )

Some havent advanced too much (as seen when Real Madrid beat LA Galaxy). But Japan/Korea, they are constantly coming out with class players all the time and keeping them in their leagues.
 

Help?

Fan Favourite
I think that the reason why european teams don't care about that competition that much, because it's not a big money maker. Winning the CL will bring in crazy money, good amount for winning the final + big revenue from 6 home matches (especially if you have a stadium like Old Trafford, Bernabeu or Camp Nou) + TV rights and bunch of others things. Same thing goes for the domestic league. The pride and bragging rights is for fans to enjoy, but the revenue is for the president and the club, and since it's the club that makes priorities, as a result the World Club Cup is not that important. Just a bonus tournament for these teams.
 

tinytim

Youth Team
-Vince- said:
tinytim has quite a history of bringing up these stupid arguments over and over again. His inferiority complex is indeed very similar to yours.

Need proof?

http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=129085
http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=124928
http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=124925
http://soccergaming.tv/showthread.php?t=125005

He can enjoy being a "World Champion" all he wants.
I, and I'm not the only one, rate this World Cup of Clubs or the International finals about as high as the Intertoto Cup. Could you imagine a fan of some random club that won it 6 years ago still going on about it? :rolleyes:


hahaha...random club? what bayern is? the 15th force of europe? c'mon...

i remember that borussia dortmund, in its golden days back in 1996, came to brazil and got its ass well kicked by palmeiras in a 6-0 score match. yea, random.

i mean...i expected that...i only wanted to see it refreshed. nice job, tinytim...

i suggest u to please stop living in this tiny, tight and wet world called uefa. very good football (many, many times better than the one played in europe) is played all around the planet. if that wasn't so...we wouldn't have zidanes, davids, eto'os, drogbas, essiens, and other fantastic players born in meaningless countries (in the football world). the proposition of fifa, based on the obvious and beautiful growth of football all around the world since the 60's, it's more than correct and it shows what's the correct vision of football: global...not continental, and definetely, not european.

i can only see 3 ways to change european's point of view about it...and not too hopeful, i say

1) a south american/african team win the germany world cup

2) brazil winning the world cup. it's gonna be six titles against 3 from germany and italy. it would take 12 years to any of them equalize it. and c'mon, let's face it...u, me, anyone else would believe that germany or italy could win 3 cups in a row. i guess that 'distance' imposed by brazil would really decrease europe's interest for a world cup...and the arrogance too.

3) fifa scheduleing and creating a true world cup of clubs, with groups and happening every two years, gathering 32 clubs. that may sound even more horrible to some european guys here...but it has a little logic (don't give a crap if ur 'wisdom' tells not) when u consider that a team like barça - with a historic lineup and gamestyle - mostly lasts 2 years, in all its 'glory'. every semifinalist of every continental cup in the last 2 years (considering asia and oceania are now together) would be qualified.
 


Top