I don't care about boots, earrings (!) and all that other crap...and please don't ruin it by adding off the ball control, because the player with the ball ie. you, cannot have a telepathic link to his teammates, smarter runs are welcome though
I'd first like to say, the core of the game is great, they need to build on top of this magnificent engine !
I want them to tweak GAMEPLAY ! Make it more realistic, tweak the physics, make a better build up game, get rid of the locked runs that they do sometimes, improve the heading syste, make players more versatile (the way the cross, shoot, keepers save etc.) and make more distinction between the teams featured (Chelsea as opposed to Man United in terms of style and fight)...
Penalties need to be a little reworked, some new animations and new features like shirt pulling, elbowing, the attacking player using his arms more goalmouth scrambles.
Low crosses need to be improved, I wanna see hard low crosses that don't float or go to slowly...
Next some licences would be good, more real shirts and an editor where we can import little images and fonts and create sponsors on the shirts, more editable shirts as well so you can create 99% perfect kits IN GAME.
earrings, tounge rings, new gel, golden teeth, colourful boots etc. are on the bottom of my priorities, waaaay at the bottom. I'm sure most WE fans aren't interested in the eye candy too much, gameplay baby gameplay !!
we are a football tribe !