• This is a reminder of 3 IMPORTANT RULES:

    1- External self-promotion websites or apps are NOT allowed here, like Discord/Twitter/Patreon/etc.

    2- Do NOT post in other languages. English-only.

    3- Crack/Warez/Piracy talk is NOT allowed.

    Breaking any of the above rules will result in your messages being deleted and you will be banned upon repetition.

    Please, stop by this thread SoccerGaming Forum Rules And Guidelines and make sure you read and understand our policies.

    Thank you!

SG's Ultimate Draft Challenge

Mandieta6

Red Card - Life
Life Ban
The funny thing is both of your RBs suck. Johnson is overrated because he's good going forward, but he's pretty lacking in defense. Rafael is of a similar mold, better in attack. Why didn't you go with a fullback that can give you stability in defense? Or a good one?

To be fair, Rafael's not that bad, and Johnson is pretty good, but they both have glaring faults.
 

Mandieta6

Red Card - Life
Life Ban
The funny thing is both of your RBs suck. Johnson is overrated because he's good going forward, but he's pretty lacking in defense. Rafael is of a similar mold, better in attack. Why didn't you go with a fullback that can give you stability in defense? Or a good one?

To be fair, Rafael's not that bad, and Johnson is pretty good, but they both have glaring faults.
 

VanTheMan

You'd better behave yourself this time!
Mandieta6;2935742 said:
The funny thing is both of your RBs suck. Johnson is overrated because he's good going forward, but he's pretty lacking in defense. Rafael is of a similar mold, better in attack. Why didn't you go with a fullback that can give you stability in defense? Or a good one?

To be fair, Rafael's not that bad, and Johnson is pretty good, but they both have glaring faults.

Az, the prob was.. I started chosing my defenders pretty late..by which many players were gone...
I am willing to play a very attacking lineup but with a very good solid spine in the center...
having rooney-fletch-vidic.. i have 3 players from the same club with good understanding who are total workoholics...
badstuber aint a bad defender either..
yes johnson is not so great...or rafael..but they aint bad either... plus when it comes to supporting your wings, these guys are excellent.
johnson is first choice for the england nt.
and he surely has delviered well enough...
rafael is like a player i can say from teh academy..i like to have this mix of veteran, exprienced and youth ...
 

VanTheMan

You'd better behave yourself this time!
oh ya and az..these are your picks so far mate..
Michael Essien - Chelsea - Ghana
Ashley Cole - Chelsea - England
Florent Malouda - Chelsea - France
Petr Cech - Chelsea - Czech Republic
Branislav Ivanovic - Chelsea - Serbia

Alex - Chelsea - Brazil
James Milner - Manchester City - England
Dimitar Berbatov - Manchester United - Bulgaria
Bobby Zamora - Fulham - England
Marouane Fellaini - Everton - Belgium
Joris Mathijsen - Hamburg - Netherlands
Paul Scholes - Manchester United - England
Yury Zhirkov - Chelsea - Russia
Steven Pienaar - Everton - South Africa
Gabriel Agbonlahor - Aston Villa - England

youve picked players solely from the premier league..and just one from outside..plus most of em chelsea guys..weras you had better options during your piick to have non chelsea better players for some like alex.
based on your selection knowledge , no offence at all..but how much do you see or know about other leagues too ?
 

Pogba4Now

Team Captain
I wonder why he chose Essien instead of Lampard. That was ridiculous. I'm sure Essien would've been available in the 2nd round.
 

Mandieta6

Red Card - Life
Life Ban
Firstly, I totally get why you made your picks, and even if I didn't, they're your picks. I just think you could've gone for much better players, but anyone could say that about anyone else. About Johnson though, most of the pundits are in agreement that he's the starting RB because there's no one else. Nicky ******* Shorey was his deputy for ****'s sake. I personally think there are better options, but he's established, and there've been worse players in the NT.

My first 4 choices are all world-class, amongst the Top 5 in their position, if not the best. Ivanovic is perfect for what I want in an RB, and he can play as CB, and by that point, he was also among the best RBs left. Alex I got because a. he's a very good CB, b. he's been playing better than usual so far and I'm tipping him for a break-out season, so I didn't want to lose him and c. I thought it was an advantage to have a CB that knows my keeper, especially because pretty much Cech's only weakness is that he sometimes miscommunicates with the defense. And Zhirkov, well, I got him late, and I already explained why I got him, he's a good back-up, and he's versatile, those are the main things.

I got mainly Prem players because they all fit into the mold I'm looking for, but basically, I watch a lot of English football, and I know these players very well. I just don't feel comfortable taking a risk on a player who is more well-known but who I don't know enough. There's been a lot of picks which I'm sure were based on reputation, or a one-time watch, and all of those guys are leaving themselves open to be torn apart by anyone who has actually seen the player enough. The only player I haven't seen play like 50 times is Mathijsen, and I've watched a lot of his matches anyway.

And yeah, I have no problem admitting that I don't like watching other leagues, it's just not as enjoyable, I still watch a few matches, but footie is something to enjoy, not work at.

You can look at the first few posts or whenever I signed him to see why I signed Essien. When I wrote down what I wanted to play, and which players I'd need, the only 2 players that I thought not getting would seriously undermine me were Essien and Cole, and no one was gonna pick a defender that early so I went with Essien. If I hadn't picked him, I'd have gone for Drogs, and I wouldn't have been able to get all of Malou, Essien and Cole as well.
 

Pogba4Now

Team Captain
Mandieta6;2935899 said:
You can look at the first few posts or whenever I signed him to see why I signed Essien. When I wrote down what I wanted to play, and which players I'd need, the only 2 players that I thought not getting would seriously undermine me were Essien and Cole, and no one was gonna pick a defender that early so I went with Essien. If I hadn't picked him, I'd have gone for Drogs, and I wouldn't have been able to get all of Malou, Essien and Cole as well.

Fair enough. Better take your key players before they're gone. But after seeing the trend in the first round, I noticed people were rather picking attacking midfielders, strikers, wingers etc. i.e. scorers, play-makers or fast wing forwards. I don't think Essien would be picked in the first round even though he's excellent (best in his position IMO). But you never know.
 

Mandieta6

Red Card - Life
Life Ban
Nady;2935903 said:
Fair enough. Better take your key players before they're gone. But after seeing the trend in the first round, I noticed people were rather picking attacking midfielders, strikers, wingers etc. i.e. scorers, play-makers or fast wing forwards. I don't think Essien would be picked in the first round even though he's excellent (best in his position IMO). But you never know.

There are only, at most, 10 players that I'm sorry I didn't get, but there's no way you can get everyone you want, and when I made my lists, I knew that guys like Zamora and Berba I would be very happy with and that they aren't going to be picked, so I was never in any rush to get an attacking player.

Seriously, whose ever turn it is, you're pissing me off. It was Yom Kippur and I still made it here, get your ******* picks in.
 

rony31

Team Captain
You bitches are taking this **** wayyyy too seriously. I would never type up a 3 paragraph argument defending my team, especially when it's as bad as Az's.
 

VanTheMan

You'd better behave yourself this time!
Mandieta6;2935899 said:
Firstly, I totally get why you made your picks, and even if I didn't, they're your picks. I just think you could've gone for much better players, but anyone could say that about anyone else. About Johnson though, most of the pundits are in agreement that he's the starting RB because there's no one else. Nicky ******* Shorey was his deputy for ****'s sake. I personally think there are better options, but he's established, and there've been worse players in the NT.

My first 4 choices are all world-class, amongst the Top 5 in their position, if not the best. Ivanovic is perfect for what I want in an RB, and he can play as CB, and by that point, he was also among the best RBs left. Alex I got because a. he's a very good CB, b. he's been playing better than usual so far and I'm tipping him for a break-out season, so I didn't want to lose him and c. I thought it was an advantage to have a CB that knows my keeper, especially because pretty much Cech's only weakness is that he sometimes miscommunicates with the defense. And Zhirkov, well, I got him late, and I already explained why I got him, he's a good back-up, and he's versatile, those are the main things.

I got mainly Prem players because they all fit into the mold I'm looking for, but basically, I watch a lot of English football, and I know these players very well. I just don't feel comfortable taking a risk on a player who is more well-known but who I don't know enough. There's been a lot of picks which I'm sure were based on reputation, or a one-time watch, and all of those guys are leaving themselves open to be torn apart by anyone who has actually seen the player enough. The only player I haven't seen play like 50 times is Mathijsen, and I've watched a lot of his matches anyway.

And yeah, I have no problem admitting that I don't like watching other leagues, it's just not as enjoyable, I still watch a few matches, but footie is something to enjoy, not work at.

You can look at the first few posts or whenever I signed him to see why I signed Essien. When I wrote down what I wanted to play, and which players I'd need, the only 2 players that I thought not getting would seriously undermine me were Essien and Cole, and no one was gonna pick a defender that early so I went with Essien. If I hadn't picked him, I'd have gone for Drogs, and I wouldn't have been able to get all of Malou, Essien and Cole as well.

Fair enough,,,, as I feel, everyone has an explanation which is valid to himself and invalid to others...its a part of human nature lol..
for example when you typed :

Alex I got because a. he's a very good CB, b. he's been playing better than usual so far and I'm tipping him for a break-out season, so I didn't want to lose him and c. I thought it was an advantage to have a CB that knows my keeper,

I can easily type... Because Rafeal is a a pretty good defender too..got listed in the PFA young player of the year award..can only get better...
Im tipping him also for a break out season soon ( he is way younger than Alex ) and thats why didnt want to lose him :innocent_smile_1:

Explanations can be generic anywer mate...no offence..
but yeah i personally feel you could have made your squad stronger by a player or two if you had concentrated a bit off- Chelsea...
But then again its my opinion, I may be wrong too
 

Mandieta6

Red Card - Life
Life Ban
rony31;2935968 said:
You bitches are taking this **** wayyyy too seriously. I would never type up a 3 paragraph argument defending my team, especially when it's as bad as Az's.

You don't have the capacity to string paragraphs together, Rony, so that's not saying much.

Van, you've pretty much said that you're making that up. I'm actually basing those things on his performances. When I say break-out season for a Chelsea player, I mean that he'll consolidate himself as a world-class player. Do you seriously think Rafael is anywhere near that level?

I disagree, I'm very happy with my picks, we'll just have to see how it pans out once we get going.
 

ShiftyPowers

Make America Great Again
I'm back. Adebayor as a risky pick... not at all. He's purely for the last 15 minutes where we completely alter our style of play to get a goal. He's big strong and fast, and that's exactly the kind of specimen I want leading my line when we're just blasting balls forward to try and equalize.

Remember everyone, you need 2 keepers. If you make a pick that makes it impossible for you to fill that requirement, your pick will not count. Backup keeper means very little, but it is one tradition that I think we should uphold. Feel free to draft someone not as well known as the backup keeper because it probably won't matter too much.

I'm desperately digging for a backup fullback. I guess I could take my boy Contento with the last pick, but... maybe I can find someone better.

Van Buyten = LOL. **** player.
 

$teauA

Superstar
$teauA;2931400 said:
----------------Howard----------------

Lahm-----Juan-------Terry-----Salcido

-----------------Mikel------------------

Walcott---------Elano---------Donovan

------------Rossi-----Suarez-----------​


Subs:
Neymar
Grafite
Ashley Young

----------------Howard----------------

Lahm-----Juan-------Terry-----Salcido

-----------------Mikel------------------

Walcott---------Elano---------Donovan

------------Rossi-----Suarez-----------​


Subs:
Neymar
Grafite
Ashley Young
Lescott
Danny

I can't believe Danny was still available.
 

Xifio

The Von Trapps


Legio Septima sixteenth round pick:

Leonardo Bonucci




AX: "Bonucci is a terrific young defender, who has all the qualities anyone would look for in a central defender. He and Ranocchia have been picked on their individual abilities, and their sensational partnership. The two boasting the second-best defensive record in the league was impressive. Doing so at Bari, with no real quality cover in front or on either side of them, was sensational."









AX: "With Simon, Leonardo, and Andrea, we have 3 terrific central defensive options. They are strong in the tackle, have excellent ground coverage, and with the shortest of the 3 standing at 190 cm, they will be a match for anyone in the air. In a team packed with attacking talent, that skill set is perfect for our centre-backs."





 


Top