The Amercian Football Discussion

bjmenge · Oct 4, 2003

I'm not the only one who thinks McNabb is overrated.

Read Here

xxxFLYERxxx · Oct 4, 2003

no ****.....why do you think he's overrated? I backed up my arguement.

ManU2000 · Oct 4, 2003

Originally posted by xxxFLYERxxx
And, Mcnabb is way beyond average. How bout that time he threw for 400 yards with a broken ankle? Mcnabb is underrated if anything, considering the **** receivers we have. If we had Randy Moss, Philly would have 2 superbowls already.

I agree. I don't know how he could be considered overrated. He's a very good quarterback. One of the best there is around.

ManU2000 · Oct 4, 2003

Last night, Miami escaped a loss by getting a game winning field goal to beat West Virginia 22-20. Frank Gore had to leave the game with a knee injury. Gore has once again torn a ligament in his knee and is out for the rest of the season again. Tough break for the guy.

ShiftyPowers · Oct 4, 2003

Originally posted by xxxFLYERxxx
And, Mcnabb is way beyond average. How bout that time he threw for 400 yards with a broken ankle? Mcnabb is underrated if anything, considering the **** receivers we have. If we had Randy Moss, Philly would have 2 superbowls already. You're insane, bjmenge.

Ok, I can say pretty much the same thing for McNair, plus he gets more injuries (and plays despite them) than McNabb but has gotten TO the Super Bowl. Since McNabb is rated better than McNair then he's overrated. Which he is in that respect.

xxxFLYERxxx · Oct 4, 2003

Going back to the original arguement: Mcnair is black too. So why didnt the liberal media try to make Mcnair look better than he is?

Back Door Skip · Oct 4, 2003

i think that mcnabb is good but not the best, but hes not overrated cause he has offence except duece staley, and he has no great recievers and he still manages to take his team deep in the playoffs twice

ShiftyPowers · Oct 5, 2003

I just said McNabb was overrated, it's not because of his race though. Limbaugh is a retard.

ManU2000 · Oct 5, 2003

Originally posted by ManU2000
Stop dreaming Stunna, USC is going to beat you guys and win the conference.

1 down, 1 to go.

#10 USC - 37
Arizona St. - 17

(H)

Bobby · Oct 5, 2003

Panthers/Saints from Charlotte today (H)

Come on panthers!

PScott · Oct 5, 2003

Originally posted by ShiftyPowers
Ok, I can say pretty much the same thing for McNair, plus he gets more injuries (and plays despite them) than McNabb but has gotten TO the Super Bowl. Since McNabb is rated better than McNair then he's overrated. Which he is in that respect.

I just have one question on this. Who rates McNabb over McNair. I remember watching NFL matchup in like the first week, and they were calling McNair the second coming of John Elway.
They were hailing him as the best quarterback in the NFL. I have heard them say McNabb is good(which he is) but i have never heard anyone say that McNabb is better than McNair.

PScott · Oct 5, 2003

Oh and i have to say that the Lions will pounce all over the 49ers today. It's Mariucci's first game against his former team, and he'll will his team to victory over the 49ers. Like Parcells' cowboys over the New York Football Giants. :rockman:

Run DMB · Oct 5, 2003

The Vikes are pretty good this season.

Kinda makes me wish I knew more about football. (:/)

Bobby · Oct 6, 2003

Panthers remain perfect (H)

Rod Smart 100 yd. Kickoff return TD, HE HATE ME!!!!

MonteMax84 · Oct 6, 2003

Originally posted by xxxFLYERxxx
Going back to the original arguement: Mcnair is black too. So why didnt the liberal media try to make Mcnair look better than he is?

Mcnair is what invalidates that Carlos*ass Limbaugh's argument. He's a black quarterback and one of the best in the league but he gets overlooked a lot by the media, and by saying that just because McNabb is black and eveyone wants him succeed makes black quarterbacks like Mcnair and Culpeeper seem worthless.

P.S.: Skins and Eagles today Flyer, What you know about them SKINS man?