WTF!! Fatmitsu scores FIFA 2005 37/40

[SuRFy]

Yeah i agree most of the PES fans start most of the fights.

 

[Hans]

Originally posted by SuRFy
Yeah i agree most of the PES fans start most of the fights.

From these two fanboy-ish quotes you can clearly see which one is a simple bashing and name-calling and which one got more maturity and facts to back their opinions :

Originally posted by McScOrPo
I just got PES4 today, and whoa is it a crock of **** or what. Gameplay is pathetic. As slow as a fart. Can only dribble in 8 directions up,down,left,right,all 4 diagonals. Dribbeling is stuttery and crap. Hit the buttons, and they dont do anything... Shooting is absolutely bollox, Free kick taking is retarded, how u suppost to aim with nothing, pitch is scled way too big, I feel like ive got akers of space. Passing is crap. half the time they dont even reach. What else did I find crap about this game hmmm, Online play is a joke, the Netcode is crap it lags like a whore. And I mean it. Tackeling is a joke, its as if theres no tackeling cod even been written, You cant tackle that simple. Slide and its a foul every time, hit the soft tackle and nothing happens.
PES4 More like PBJES (Pro Big Joke Evolution Soccer)

FIFA is the king of football, after playign PES and seeing it my self. Who ever thinks its better doesnt have a leg to stand on, It's appauling im taking it back to the shops tommorow waste of £30.

Absolute Joke of a game, Embarasses the name of good Football.

my two cents

Originally posted by mike86
ONLY FACTS


FIFA 2005 - Gamespot: rating 8.9 | user rating 7.9
http://www.gamespot.com/pc/sports/fifasoccer2005/index.html
PES4 - Gamespot : rating -- | user rating 9.0
http://www.gamespot.com/pc/sports/proevolutionsoccer4/index.html?q=pes4


FIFA 2005 - Eurogamer: rating 8 of 10
http://www.eurogamer.net/article.php?article_id=56842
PES4 - Eurogamer: rating 9 of 10
http://www.eurogamer.net/article.php?article_id=56938

FIFA 2005 - IGN: rating 8.6 -- user rating 8.0
http://pc.ign.com/objects/681/681801.html
PES4 - IGN: rating -- user rating: 9.3
http://pc.ign.com/objects/691/691288.html


FIFA 2005 - 6 out of 10
http://www.rewiredmind.com/review.php?r=325
PES4 - Rewiremind : 10out of 10
http://www.rewiredmind.com/review.php?r=321


FIFA 2005 - IC-Games: Overall Score: 81%
http://www.ic-games.co.uk/index.php?location=1&&articleid=2183
PES4 - IC-Games: Overall Score: 88%
http://www.ic-games.co.uk/index.php?location=1&&articleid=2160


FIFA 2005 - UK special: 9/10 (from 28 reviews)
http://uk.special.reserve.co.uk/q_WV1049_fifa_2005_online.html
PES4 - UK special: 10/10 (form 33 reviews)
http://uk.special.reserve.co.uk/q_WV1178_pro_evolution_socc.html


PES4 - GRY Interia: rating 9.5/10
http://gry.interia.pl/news?inf=543231

And for generalization:

FIFA 2005 : - 85%
http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages4/920612.asp
PES4 : 95%
http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/921670.asp?q=pro evolution soccer

And what about that :

FIFA 2005 = Soccergaming 8.5/10
http://www.soccergaming.com/db/reviews/show.php?RID=44
PES3 (äà PES3) = Soccergaming 9.5/10
http://www.soccergaming.com/db/reviews/show.php?RID=38

So who's the champion now - PES4 !!!

p.p.
FIFA - R.I.P

I can give you lots and I mean a lot of proves of FIFA fanboys started the name calling like "PES whore", etc when they`re running out of arguments, but then again you`ll probably just gonna call me a pathetic guy with nothing to do.

So get your facts straight or else just shut up . . .

 

[deftonesmx17]

bring the proof on that FIFA fans start with the name calling, and i will bring you all the proof of the PES fans doing it. i will call you guys one name, then again this is not name calling, it is just stating facts, ONLY FACTS. PES fan=hypocrit, you guys say one thing over here in the PES vs FIFA forum and then once on your own turf you complain about the exact things in PES that you say are better about it. gets me laughing every time

 

[soccerulez]

Originally posted by deftonesmx17
bring the proof on that FIFA fans start with the name calling, and i will bring you all the proof of the PES fans doing it. i will call you guys one name, then again this is not name calling, it is just stating facts, ONLY FACTS. PES fan=hypocrit, you guys say one thing over here in the PES vs FIFA forum and then once on your own turf you complain about the exact things in PES that you say are better about it. gets me laughing every time

Shut up! we dont need yr opinion

 

[Shaft085]

Forums are about voicing opinions. Regardless if you agree with them or Not, everybody,s entitled to one.

But i have noticed in many forums , that everytime this PES v Fifa topic is mentioned, there always seems to be an air of Arrogance about the PES Fans, replies.. Usually consisting of blunt one line answers like...
" Fifa is S**t! " ... " PES is 10 times Better "... " PES is the Best! " or " PES is Real Football! "... But rarely do you get an explanation why...

Neither do you get many PES fans giving honest reviews, stating the Pro,s & Con,s of Both games...
So it isn,t hard to see where the conflicts, come from..

 

[Shaft085]

Getting back to Topic ...
I personaly wouldn,t pay too much to Any Magazine or Site rating, as the scoring could also be down to the reviewers personal fav.
Like if you are a PES fan then PES4 is always going to get an higher rating than Fifa05, and visa versa ...

But i do pay attention to the end of year U.K and Worldwide Sales Charts.
What is suprising is the fact that regardless how poor Fifa apparently is each year, it always manages to sell more units than PES.
With last year being no different.

Also may i state that this is after checking 5-6 different gaming sites.
I will agree that this is mainly down to Fifa,s Licensing advantage.
But it does go to show the amount of people that still enjoy & play the game.
Even though we are constantly told on forums, that the whole world has jumped ship to PES, as it,s a Far better simulation of Football...

 

[Rport03]

Id like to first start off thank you Shaft for both of your posts because your actually explaining sometihng.

Well you guys always talk about the facts, both PES and FIFA fans, im a FIFA fan but here are my facts I play the game I like. Not only in FIFA but in many other games I don't usually take what critics say to heart and base my choices on them. I buy the game if I don't like it I return it. Most fo you say that PES fans dont name call or whatever. Im not someone to argue with people about a game but in this section anways I see the PES fans cry more than FIFA fans. Like I stated before in this thread about the first post. Just because someone gave the game you like a bad score you started crying and saying they dont know anything etc. You people have to realize that the world doesnt revolve around you, nor any game or whatever. Accept the fact that people have there own opinions, and you say this is a forum to voice your opinion well dont cry because someone voiced theres.

Most of you proably dont play the FIFA games but argue facts of what your heard or read by other people.

All in all just play the game you like and even though this section is about PES vs FIFA just give both games a fair arguement and stop cring. to both PES and FIFA fans alike.