I play PES and have done so for the last 2 years , before I played FIFA well being PC owner I could do nothing else ... And FIFA was ok but 03 while not the worst it was not great 04 done it for me I never went near 05 ...
Now after playing PES for 2 years , what I can talk about is ball movement , and after non stop playing of the 06 demo and putting in the line to help frame rate, it didn't really help the ball movement at all ...
Now before anyone calls me a fanBOY , I am 47 - 48 on the 25th of this month !
I want to play the best football game I can and I don't care if its Konami's of EA's but at the moment its Konami's! Even with its flaws ....
The ball in the 06 demo does seem to skate along the grass in passing mode , and when that transfers to "in the air" be it lob or goalkicks or shots, then the ball does move in different ways. Lobs are like lead ballons (for want of a better way to discribe it) goalkick on the up arc seem smooth put on the down arc looks like there being held back, and shot travel far to fast. The whole ball physics give the game an unreal feeling to it, now I know FR had something to do with what I was seeing but not all..
FR would make the ball look jerky , but then again in the same game the ball ran along the grass as if it was on glass or ice! so FR doesn't tell the whole story. It was the way the ball travelled in flight its path(s) and be they smooth or jerky is not the main point, its the way the ball moves in flight at times it looks as light as a feather and others like a medicine ball.
Now if EA's want to make an Arcade football game dressed as footballing sim, then that is fine, if people want pick up and play fun then FIFA's the game... But if like me, your more into "being as close as any game can be to the real thing" (and PES still has a long way to go , its not perfect) but its PES for me ....
My dream ticket would be PES's gameplay = AI Ball Physics and yes even some of the player kits graphics! Matched with FIFA's whole footballing presentation and real teams, kits league setups..
Both games have there place in the gaming world , but my dream of a hybrid PES/FIFA game will have to wait ...