• This is a reminder of 3 IMPORTANT RULES:

    1- External self-promotion websites or apps are NOT allowed here, like Discord/Twitter/Patreon/etc.

    2- Do NOT post in other languages. English-only.

    3- Crack/Warez/Piracy talk is NOT allowed.

    Breaking any of the above rules will result in your messages being deleted and you will be banned upon repetition.

    Please, stop by this thread SoccerGaming Forum Rules And Guidelines and make sure you read and understand our policies.

    Thank you!

FIFA gets 6/10 at Soccer Gaming review.

Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Sukur54

Senior Squad
First of all to all you review knowers out there. The definition for review is this:
To write or give a critical report on (a new work or performance, for example)
So why is someones review getting rejected if it doesnt go againts the rules of the forum unless the forums rules are to be nice as possible to EA SPORTS.Freedom of speech is what this country and this forum is about and if we cant do it
 
V

valioso

Fan Favourite
you're refusing to post a review because you dont agree with the score? but if he says is a 7.5 and writes the same thing inside you would post it? dude, I dont care if its your site or not, you know your site is a major reference when it comes to fifa, and if someone reads the game is an 8 and sees a review that gives a 6 then will probably read both.
I just have major problems with censorship, on the other hand I dont believe for one second that EA people read this forums and choose in that case to completely ignore what people have been saying for a long long long time.
 
Matt Holme

Matt Holme

Founder
Moderator
I'm kind of wasting my time here I see. I say something, and then people come out and think I'm talking about a review in this forum (Sukr54, we're not talking about posting a review in this forum, anyone can post a review in this forum). And once again, people are trying to tell me to let Joe have his own opinion. It must have been literally 6 or 7 times now I've said that I don't mind if people have their own opinion. But I see I'm getting no where.

Please guys (other mods), just let me close the topic. Theres no more insults flying so there is no need for it to continue or people to get their own back. We've lost the plot a bit.
 
J

Joe

Starting XI
No Matt, they're talking about a review at your website. How it seems like that you will accept other reviews, but only if it's your opinion of the game. I mean, dude!--you just told me what the score of the review should be! Who's opinion is it then? Why have two reviews when you just told me what the review should be? It makes no sense and is utter BS.
 
J

Joe

Starting XI
So, for the record:

You are basically telling EVERYONE here. That you will not post any review that does not suit your opinion? IS THAT CORRECT? I have an idea for you--go join CNN. They do that all the time. It's called propaganda and censoring when it deals with real life stuff. You'd probably enjoy it. You may also be interested in the Communist government. ;)
 
Matt Holme

Matt Holme

Founder
Moderator
6/10 means the game is crap and useless. FIFA 2003 isn't crap and useless. 7.5/10 is correct as it shows a game that is flawed, but still fun.
 
J

Joe

Starting XI
No, thats not what I'm saying.

This is what I'm saying:

6/10 means the game is crap and useless. FIFA 2003 isn't crap and useless. 7.5/10 is correct as it shows a game that is flawed, but still fun.

5-7 means the game is average. 8-10 means the game is good/excellent. 1-4 means the game is subpar and crap. I said I would give it a 6.5. No more.
 
Matt Holme

Matt Holme

Founder
Moderator
That is what I said :P

Joe and I have agreed to do a joint PS2 review. In it we will both post our comments on the PS2 version and each give a score. Then we'll take an average of the two scores and that score can be the official SG score for the game. So expect our joint review shortly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Top