Who is the most complete midfielder?

[Rob]

Frank Lampard.

 

[Amdy Faye]

So Ballack's better than Gerrard? Make a poll n see

 

[renege]

Originally posted by Amdy Faye
So Ballack's better than Gerrard? Make a poll n see

did you just get internet access.
WTF?

 

[Amdy Faye]

Lmao, ^ this guys certain Ballack's better... Umm.. How so?

 

[RealMatriX]

zidane is a playmaker, how the hell can he be the most complete midfielder.. vieira is definitely the most complete, b/c he helps in both defense and offense

 

[santino]

romas emerson, wheres he? solid dm, and makes the attacking run here and there

and where's pirlo? another dm, that has great vision with his passing

but since neither is up there im gonna have to say davids, look what happened to juve without him

 

[dannyeli]

Did someone saw what seedorf did today ? that's a midfielder

 

[Amdy Faye]

Yea the goals! His 2nd wit his left as well! Woaaaa, hair looks silly tho, where is the

 

[Your Maw]

Viera .

 

[Delly]

Originally posted by Amdy Faye
Umm I agree you have a few good players, Makkay, Ze Roberto, Lucio, Rosicky. But that isnt enough if you want to compare league for league player for player, the premiership has a better variety, fact.

Uhh, well let me break down the "some" good players that play in Germany IMO.

Kahn, Hargreaves, Makaay, Ze Roberto, Ballack, Sagnol, Salihamidzic, Santa Cruz, Worns, Metzelder, Koller, Amoroso, Dede, Kehl, Rosicky, Evanilson, Lucio, Basturk, Nowotny, Placente

And that's only from 3 clubs.

 

[FosterjR2k4]

Originally posted by Groogster
Another amazing player (Beckam) and i will tell you the reason for not being in this poll.

By complete i mean a midfielder that can play as well in defense and in ofense. If you look at the players listed you´ll notice that every single one of them has good ofense and defense capabilities and overall balance in the two aspects of the game

Thanks mate

I reckon Zidane has easily won this 1

 

[Hendrik]

Originally posted by Amdy Faye
In my opinion Gerrard is better and I think Ballack is hardly criticised because he is seen as a 'big' german player, so people respect that, but if you actually watch him play, he is no better than any of England's midfielders,

Thanks for the laugh.

 

[henry#14]

Originally posted by valioso
Zidane is not a complete midfielder.. he does not play defence

yeah. tho i reckon you should not have put CAM's like Zidane because they have no responsibilities to defend. and i wanna slap the fool who mentioned Steven Gerrard. maybe i'll mention Jermaine Jenas

 

[RUSI]

I'd say that Ballack is the most complete midfielder.

He does everything.

Zidane doesn't play much D so i wouldn't call him the most complete, though he is the best

Nedved and Lampard are very complete aswell

 

[buzzer555]

Ballack gets my vote.

 

[SB9Dragon]

I'm really starting to think that a lot of guys on these forums don't understand what the term "complete" means. I mean seriously, how is Zidane winning this by a landslide??

 

[Amdy Faye]

Originally posted by Delly
Uhh, well let me break down the "some" good players that play in Germany IMO.

Kahn, Hargreaves, Makaay, Ze Roberto, Ballack, Sagnol, Salihamidzic, Santa Cruz, Worns, Metzelder, Koller, Amoroso, Dede, Kehl, Rosicky, Evanilson, Lucio, Basturk, Nowotny, Placente

And that's only from 3 clubs.

Umm yea? We're talking about the most complete player, I just think it's funny everyone loves Ballack, pfft think what you like

 

[KoreaJjang]

Vieira!! He can defend, tackle, and pass brilliantly
He also is strong and tall!!

 

[jani]

Vieira, Davids, Seedorf and Emerson

Pirlo would need to improve his defending skills a bit and he'll be the best in a few yrs time

 

[FosterjR2k4]

I'm really starting to think that a lot of guys on these forums don't understand what the term "complete" means. I mean seriously, how is Zidane winning this by a landslide??

Zidane is the best in the list so in reality nobody cares what a complete midefielder is. ya shud of made a poll who is the best midfielder.